Rendered at 17:13:23 GMT+0000 (Coordinated Universal Time) with Cloudflare Workers.
tejtm 1 days ago [-]
Thanks for the second chance on this HN!
This is important (to me) because the proprietary windows software "VARA"
has a de facto death grip on basic emergency amateur radio digital communication.
A clean room open source rust implementation called xara was just shut down
forks could happen, but if any get traction,
they will most likely suffer the same fate.
So wide spread adoption of a complete alternative
such as this HERMES and Mercury project seem the best choice.
This project the ARDC is funding targets needs in third world communities.
But please keep in mind we are all one natural disaster away
from needing it as well.
anelson 24 hours ago [-]
^ This!
VARA’s developer released a new version 4.9.1 which had a logic bomb that completely breaks compatibility with all prior versions starting on 1 Jan 2027. Coincidentally this was released shortly after Xara (an open source AI-assisted reimplementation of VARA that was fully compatible with VARA over the air) was published. It was the work of a few minutes with an LLM to extract the new tables and constants from the new binary, so he failed to prevent interoperability with open source implementations but succeeded in doing significant damage to interoperability in the community as hams don’t always update components like this in a timely fashion. Poor judgement at best and bad faith at worst.
It’s definitely time for the amateur radio and emcomm communities to move on.
I have a fork of the now-pulled Xara repo. As of this writing it hasn’t been taken down yet but several other forks were so time will tell: https://github.com/anelson/xara
Mercury is promising. There’s also Data2G and I and others are working on our own modem projects as well. It’s an exciting time to be working with digital modes on amateur radio.
cge 20 hours ago [-]
>It was the work of a few minutes with an LLM to extract the new tables and constants from the new binary, so he failed to prevent interoperability with open source implementations but succeeded in doing significant damage to interoperability in the community as hams don’t always update components like this in a timely fashion.
In case people outside of amateur radio aren't aware of how weird this is: as far as I can understand, modes like these used for amateur radio transmissions are legally required by the FCC to have complete, publicly available documentation sufficient to understand them. VARA doesn't, the developer seems to actively work against the ability to have independent implementations, and there are reverse engineering projects which, from a legal perspective, seem like they shouldn't need to exist.
And as far as I can tell, no one with any power around US amateur radio cares. Beyond the FCC never doing anything, if I remember correctly, there are even questions on the FCC's ham radio exams that are essentially advertisements for VARA.
ronsor 23 hours ago [-]
> VARA’s developer released a new version 4.9.1 which had a logic bomb that completely breaks compatibility with all prior versions starting on 1 Jan 2027.
Is there more coverage? That sounds downright evil.
anelson 17 hours ago [-]
Nothing official from
the VARA developer afaik.
I participated in some discussion on a private discord where the claim was made that the developer did this. I reversed the binary with an LLM and confirmed it myself. I’m aware of at least one ham radio YouTuber who has posted a video about this.
I presume it will get more coverage as more people learn about the new release and the compatibility break.
If you can find anything like release notes you are doing better than I did.
A web search for
"VARA version 4.9.1 incompatibility"
brings up as much coverage as you are apt to find.
postoplust 1 days ago [-]
> This is important (to me) because the proprietary windows software "VARA" has a de facto death grip on basic emergency amateur radio digital communication.
This fact keeps me out of many ARES exercises. I avoid buying or using proprietary solutions on amateur bands.
phendrenad2 17 hours ago [-]
Um, if it was clean-room, how was it shut down? Did they get a legal threat or something?
slow_typist 1 days ago [-]
I wonder on which bands they operate. In most jurisdictions you cannot forward messages as a service under ham regulations, apart from disaster recovery situations.
justarobert 1 days ago [-]
I was only briefly a ham decades ago, so I could be remembering wrong. but isn't it a thing to relay even non emergency messages for a third party as long as it's not commercial? I remember getting a postcard where the message content was from a ham I had talked to, but the postcard itself was sent by someone closer that he relayed the message to. I though it was a common novelty/courtesy thing from back when long distance phone calling was a bigger deal.
After looking into this for a while, it seems implied that HERMES usage in some, if not many, of these remote locations is not really legally authorized, or is in jurisdictions where the legal framework for HF itself is unclear or practically unenforced.
Even beyond forwarding and ham licensing, it seems like many of the HERMES deployments of the sort discussed in the article are using encryption, and need to use encryption for their use cases.
CamperBob2 1 days ago [-]
You can forward messages as a ham operator, even to the extent of connecting long-distance telephone calls, as long as nobody including you is getting paid for it.
This has led to some subtle questions -- is it OK to use a packet-radio gateway to order a pizza over the Internet? -- but the volunteer/public-service nature of the act is the intent behind the regulations.
This is important (to me) because the proprietary windows software "VARA" has a de facto death grip on basic emergency amateur radio digital communication.
A clean room open source rust implementation called xara was just shut down
https://github.com/x0rro/xara
forks could happen, but if any get traction, they will most likely suffer the same fate.
So wide spread adoption of a complete alternative such as this HERMES and Mercury project seem the best choice.
This project the ARDC is funding targets needs in third world communities.
But please keep in mind we are all one natural disaster away from needing it as well.
VARA’s developer released a new version 4.9.1 which had a logic bomb that completely breaks compatibility with all prior versions starting on 1 Jan 2027. Coincidentally this was released shortly after Xara (an open source AI-assisted reimplementation of VARA that was fully compatible with VARA over the air) was published. It was the work of a few minutes with an LLM to extract the new tables and constants from the new binary, so he failed to prevent interoperability with open source implementations but succeeded in doing significant damage to interoperability in the community as hams don’t always update components like this in a timely fashion. Poor judgement at best and bad faith at worst.
It’s definitely time for the amateur radio and emcomm communities to move on.
I have a fork of the now-pulled Xara repo. As of this writing it hasn’t been taken down yet but several other forks were so time will tell: https://github.com/anelson/xara
Mercury is promising. There’s also Data2G and I and others are working on our own modem projects as well. It’s an exciting time to be working with digital modes on amateur radio.
In case people outside of amateur radio aren't aware of how weird this is: as far as I can understand, modes like these used for amateur radio transmissions are legally required by the FCC to have complete, publicly available documentation sufficient to understand them. VARA doesn't, the developer seems to actively work against the ability to have independent implementations, and there are reverse engineering projects which, from a legal perspective, seem like they shouldn't need to exist.
And as far as I can tell, no one with any power around US amateur radio cares. Beyond the FCC never doing anything, if I remember correctly, there are even questions on the FCC's ham radio exams that are essentially advertisements for VARA.
Is there more coverage? That sounds downright evil.
I participated in some discussion on a private discord where the claim was made that the developer did this. I reversed the binary with an LLM and confirmed it myself. I’m aware of at least one ham radio YouTuber who has posted a video about this.
I presume it will get more coverage as more people learn about the new release and the compatibility break.
If you can find anything like release notes you are doing better than I did.
A web search for
"VARA version 4.9.1 incompatibility"
brings up as much coverage as you are apt to find.
This fact keeps me out of many ARES exercises. I avoid buying or using proprietary solutions on amateur bands.
Even beyond forwarding and ham licensing, it seems like many of the HERMES deployments of the sort discussed in the article are using encryption, and need to use encryption for their use cases.
This has led to some subtle questions -- is it OK to use a packet-radio gateway to order a pizza over the Internet? -- but the volunteer/public-service nature of the act is the intent behind the regulations.