Rendered at 16:57:11 GMT+0000 (Coordinated Universal Time) with Cloudflare Workers.
ecto 38 minutes ago [-]
Hey HN,
I submitted this thread a few days ago and woke up to it on the front page. If anyone would like to discuss the ideas, feel free to email me. I won't be here to argue any longer.
My hope is that before you write your next comment, you consider the person on the other side of the screen.
I'm doing my best. Maybe it isn't up to your standards, but it's what I have. Criticizing my use of AI is pissing in the wind. I'm on my last leg financially, have a family and little free time, and just want to make the world better with the few good ideas I have.
I hope you have a nice day.
JoeDohn 5 hours ago [-]
My first thought when I read (skimmed mostly) the paper is PGO (Profile guide optimization), except instead of optimizing machine code based on runtime profiling, this would optimize geometry based on physical or engineering objectives ?
So, the Claude English to human English translation:
Ordinarily, if you want to adjust the parameters of a CAD part, say, a bracket, to meet a constraint like a particular mass or center of mass, the approach is to change every parameter a little, rebuild the geometry to see what physical properties changes, and repeat until you get the result you wanted.
This is of course a very expensive operation because you have to iterate through every parameter on a part every single time for any optimization pass.
So VCAD's approach is to essentially record how each of the mesh verticies connect to each other after the BRep tesselates, then calculate what part of the mesh are actually affected when a parameter change, and then use that to guide their optimizer to get the physical result they wanted, so they only need to change the relevant parameters they found that affects properties instead of doing the computational equivalent of banging your head against the keyboard and hoping something works.
bschwindHN 5 hours ago [-]
Thank you! It's a shame there are so many LLMisms in this paper, it really cheapens the whole thing and makes it harder to understand than it needs to be.
Write papers and articles in your own words, people!
ecto 4 hours ago [-]
Frankly, I have not the time. I have a son, a business, and research to complete. Let people live. I don't care if the words cheapen it for you - I present my ideas for the world to enjoy.
programjames 3 hours ago [-]
I think it is pretty well done and far above the quality of most papers. I also think the prose is not up to the same standard you applied for the places where you made choices (e.g. presentation, layout, communicating key ideas). But I totally understand where you are coming from. It takes a ton of work to apply theory of mind to figure out how to say things intuitively for your audience (the main gap of LLM prose here), probably 10x the work of carefully choosing what ideas and in what order to communicate them.
ecto 2 hours ago [-]
Thank you for taking the time to read, and provide useful feedback. I hope you have a great day :)
iamsam123 3 hours ago [-]
Presenting your ideas is one of the most important parts of research…
ecto 3 hours ago [-]
The ideas are presented how I intend, after months of work.
itishappy 2 hours ago [-]
Dismissible? I get the feeling like you don't have time to finish this. It feels like a hobby project that I may need to fight through to get value from.
Now, I might not be the intended audience! If your audience is toolmakers who will build your ideas into their own products, then you're on the right track, and I'll wait to see what they build with this!
LtdJorge 3 hours ago [-]
Does that mean you don’t care about the time of people reading your research, if it makes it more difficult to read?
I submitted this thread a few days ago and woke up to it on the front page. If anyone would like to discuss the ideas, feel free to email me. I won't be here to argue any longer.
My hope is that before you write your next comment, you consider the person on the other side of the screen.
I'm doing my best. Maybe it isn't up to your standards, but it's what I have. Criticizing my use of AI is pissing in the wind. I'm on my last leg financially, have a family and little free time, and just want to make the world better with the few good ideas I have.
I hope you have a nice day.
Ordinarily, if you want to adjust the parameters of a CAD part, say, a bracket, to meet a constraint like a particular mass or center of mass, the approach is to change every parameter a little, rebuild the geometry to see what physical properties changes, and repeat until you get the result you wanted.
This is of course a very expensive operation because you have to iterate through every parameter on a part every single time for any optimization pass.
So VCAD's approach is to essentially record how each of the mesh verticies connect to each other after the BRep tesselates, then calculate what part of the mesh are actually affected when a parameter change, and then use that to guide their optimizer to get the physical result they wanted, so they only need to change the relevant parameters they found that affects properties instead of doing the computational equivalent of banging your head against the keyboard and hoping something works.
Write papers and articles in your own words, people!
Now, I might not be the intended audience! If your audience is toolmakers who will build your ideas into their own products, then you're on the right track, and I'll wait to see what they build with this!