Rendered at 17:21:07 GMT+0000 (Coordinated Universal Time) with Cloudflare Workers.
blinkingled 2 days ago [-]
Total KDE fan and that's all I run at home. It's an interesting study also in desktop environment and software written in C++ and just how hard it is to get something that works for most people. Mistakes, corrections, building the basic blocks like Qt in the early days and keeping a bunch of people with differing cultures / tastes / backgrounds/needs motivated to make it better every day - fascinating achievement.
Thank you KDE folks - I contribute in terms of bug reports and attempts at fixes sometimes but this time I am signing up for a monthly donation - I encourage people to do what they can to keep a good thing going! https://kde.org/donate/
fasterik 2 days ago [-]
Agreed. I'm a late-comer to KDE, having used Linux for over 20 years but only switched to KDE in the past year. Too many annoying design decisions in GNOME and I got sick of wasting time configuring the trendy minimalist WMs. I find KDE to be a breath of fresh air. It's got sensible defaults, gets out of my way for the most part, and it's improved a lot since I last tried it in the mid-2000s.
mistyvales 2 days ago [-]
I also use KDE daily and need to add it to my yearly donations list (alongside FreeBSD, Signal, Bottles, and a few others).
brnt 2 days ago [-]
Im a KDE user since the early Plasma 5 days, which is now more than a decade ago. It's awesome, usable, configurable, sleek and fun!
A week ago I bought a cheap mini-htpc and put Plasma Bigscreen on it, using a phone with KDEconnect as remote. So easy to use! So much better than AndroidTV let alone proprietary crap.
KDE is just great.
Barrin92 2 days ago [-]
KDE connect for me is honestly the killer app in the whole ecosystem. In general at this point I'm less excited about the desktop itself because I've always lived in Emacs or the browser and most desktops more or less work these days, but the support system KDE has built around makes it stand out to me.
Connect, KdenLive, Krita, KFind and a whole bunch of other stuff is very useful.
IndySun 1 days ago [-]
> "KDE connect for me is honestly the killer app in the whole ecosystem"
Does KDE Connect cover some of the usefulness of Tailscale?
Yeah, additionally anyone at Microsoft that keeps throwing out half usable COM frameworks for C++ should spend some time with KParts, KIO and Qt D-Bus bindings, maybe they would finally learn how to properly design one.
esFran 2 days ago [-]
KDE is amazing. Outstanding performance, outstanding design, and endlessly configurable. But the most amazing thing of all is that you've achieved this while competing against teams like Microsoft's or Apple's, which spend millions of euros and are made up of thousands of people.
Congratulations, team. Here's to 30 more years.
kombine 1 days ago [-]
Most incredibly KDE team managed to build something miles better than both Apple and Microsoft. I briefly had to use Macbook when I started in my job last year, but eventually I made them order a PC laptop for me where I put Linux with KDE Plasma which is what I've been running on my personal computers for years. KDE is significantly more ergonomic.
latexr 1 days ago [-]
I’m not sure one can make a sensible argument for what is more ergonomic (in an objective sense) after using the alternatives only briefly. Familiarity plays a huge part in our opinions. In most operating systems I’ve used for a while, I found something odd that felt awkward but made sense after being immersed in and understanding the thought being the decisions. That doesn’t mean I always agreed, but it’s important to recognise ergonomics are always subjective—at different times we have different body shapes and ways of thinking so one person’s discomfort is another’s perfect fit.
Really genuinely glad you found the thing that works for you (and that your company accommodated it), that’s what matters.
Last I looked at KDE was some two decades ago and didn’t like it visually, but since then I’ve been curious to give it another shot.
kombine 1 days ago [-]
You are right in a sense that I've developed Linux habits and muscle memory over years which make it difficult to use Apple computers. Having said that, I find KDE and Plasma an order of magnitude more powerful than Mac OS. I won't recall the specifics as I haven't used it a lot hut it pretty much every component is better in KDE: main bar, system tray, system settings app, window management, display configuration, file browser, PDF reader and so on
aruggirello 18 hours ago [-]
KDE Connect, Kate, Kaffeine, Okular, the Event Calendar add-on widget, keyboard management, selection as an alternate clipboard (for those coming from Windows/Mac), window programming... And Dolphin, _THE_ file manager. Now if only Dolphin could be made to integrate with Kitty instead of Konsole, and Kitty would show scrollbars, the world would be perfect!
NotCamelCase 1 days ago [-]
So, what's the most straightforward (headache-free!) KDE distro nowadays? Kubuntu?
I've stuck to Ubuntu since it's what I learned about the first during university, but I unfortunately notice that Ubuntu 26.04 is by far the least polished Ubuntu version I've ever used, so I'm inclined to do the switch.
aruggirello 18 hours ago [-]
Kubuntu has been the reference KDE distro in the past, before KDE Neon. It's still a valid choice, especially if you know your way around Ubuntu (you might also consider Debian though) - keep in mind Kubuntu 24.04 LTS is EOL in ~6 months (Canonical sells extended support though), but will install X11 by default, is rock solid/battle tested, and you can then update to 26.04 and retain X11; while a fresh Kubuntu 26.04 install defaults to Wayland; X11 support is going to be removed anyway (by 28.04?), so we'll probably be forced to migrate to Wayland in a couple years or so...
0l 1 days ago [-]
Probably Fedora KDE, which recently became its own edition (and not just a spin) so is very well supported/tested.
noisy_boy 23 hours ago [-]
Having seen installation issues with Kubuntu (weird errors), I tried Fedrora + KDE and it was smooth. Been using that for over an year now and no regrets at all. My distro and desktop switching itch has been fully scratched and hopefully this continues to be home for the foreseeable future, fingers crossed.
KDE is how desktops should be. 'The Year of the Linux' is NOW, a few years ago. Linux and KDE have given me not only freedom over my own hardware, but freedom over how I interact with my desktops. Once you know the shortcuts, things become so much more fun. Much love to the KDE team.
Linux life, yo.
mongol 2 days ago [-]
I am a bit prod of having seen the original post looking for volunteers to build a Kool Desktop Environment. I was obsessively reading Usenet groups at the time. And I remember there were quite early betas published, I did not run them at first, but I remember much enthusiasm about it. So I feel familiar with the beginnings although I never participated in the project development-wise. All the way up to KDE 4 I was quite close to the project as a user. But since KDE 4 was so unstable and buggy, I left it around that time. This is also around the time when the documentary makes a big jump ahead chronologically.
I feel the documentary explains less what happened the last 10-15 years. I recall Trolltech and Qt underwent a series of acquisitions. How is KDE and Qt developed now? Who are the main contributors and sponsors? Any big backers? This information I felt missing.
bayindirh 2 days ago [-]
The problems in KDE 4.0 & 4.1 is long gone. It was at 3.5.x level around 4.6, and now it's just smooth and invisible. You can surely give another try.
Qt is now its own company, namely Qt Group. Wikipedia quotes:
> In 2018, the company had 5,000 customers. Approximately 80% of the Fortune 500 companies are customers of Qt Group.[22]
So it's self-sustaining now.
AFAIK, KDE is still mostly volunteer work, but the way they develop software is pretty robust.
account42 4 hours ago [-]
The problems of KDE 4 are definitely not gone. And the mindset that created them remains. I haven't seen one KDE dev even acknowledge the mistake that 4.0 was - instead they always blame others for the mess.
bayindirh 4 hours ago [-]
Can you point some of the problems so I can be aware of them, and if possible I can file some bug reports for them?
Currently I fail to see big problems while I daily drive this thing, but mine might be a bias, of course.
Sammi 2 days ago [-]
Valve has been contracting KDE devs to fix bugs and add features for years now, as KDE is the desktop environment on SteamOS.
bayindirh 2 days ago [-]
Good to know, thanks. I was more involved in KDE in the past years, but I don't have that amount of time now, so I missed these things, I believe.
However, KDE rocks. My colleagues called me "a maniac" once when they see how I use that thing (i.e. Dolphin + KIO + fast window switches + multiple desktops).
tapland 2 days ago [-]
I need top look up a cheat sheet or something, I am way too bad at navigating around plasma and dolphin
arkapravac366 2 days ago [-]
[flagged]
hxorr 1 days ago [-]
One thing it also did not cover is, how does one patch KDE2 under FreeBSD?
I work at Qt and I would say the focus is not at all on the open source Qt. It’s actually kind of a burden for us since it can eat some commercial sales. I think many of us at Qt often wish it wasn’t free
sirtaj 1 days ago [-]
It was in preparation of this exact scenario that the free qt agreement was put in place. KDE developers were pretty miffed at the drama around this at the time (basing a free environment on a toolkit that could go full proprietary at any time, leading to GNOME), but I'm pretty sure most are happy about it now. What an awful waste it would have been if Qt had ended up proprietary after all.
account42 4 hours ago [-]
I think that's pretty short sighted. How relevant do you expect Qt to be if it wasn't open source in the first place?
bowsamic 18 minutes ago [-]
Not much of our sales are riding on the Qt name or technology
kombine 1 days ago [-]
So the free marketing as well as contributions and testing from KDE community don't play a role?
bowsamic 22 minutes ago [-]
Not really, no
ezst 2 days ago [-]
I joined as a user at one point during the kde3 days, powerful apps like Amarok 1.4, k3b and konqueror with all kinds of crazy kio-slaves were the ones that really gave me pause on the boot screen and kept tipping me over towards mandrake instead of WinXP ("why can't it be that simple and as well integrated, why do I need so many ad-hoc shareware to do every basic thing like burning/ripping CDs, mounting ISOs, transcoding audio, sending it to my MP3 player").
The KDE4 days were rough, by then I had jumped over to fedora, and that one didn't shy away from shipping very early and unstable versions of it. That had me hopping for alternative DEs, I seriously tried several (and stuck for a while with some) of the minimalistic ones (enlightenment, XFCE, ...) and quickly ended up depending on either KWin, and/or some battery/networking/disks applet from plasma, or configuring something via systemsettings. The plasma desktop itself is fine (I don't mind it so much, I'm not crazy about shell theming and customisations, I do love my global menu on top, though), but what sells KDE for me is all the clever ancillary stuff that makes it "smart and usable" (dealing with Bluetooth, network setup, local and remote drives, audio output, ...), that's where the "environment" metaphor kicks in and elevates the experience above that of a "desktop shell".
pndy 2 days ago [-]
> The KDE4 days were rough
Back then whenever I had a chance to try a distro with KDE 4, the Crash Handler window would pop after doing stupidest and simplest things within the desktop. Gnome 3 wasn't any better - it was more stable but departing from desktop metaphor to this mobile-desktop hybrid made me avoid it and pick Xfce instead. Which is shame because KDE4 despite the problems looked really well (and still does); I once said here that it had this "younger sister of Vista's Aero" vibe. It's really cool that they managed to bring Oxygen theme back.
exe34 2 days ago [-]
I also left Kde at the 4.0 time, and for a while was on Mac OS X, but nowadays I've given up on desktop environments - I just use xmonad and dmenu, and a mishmash of apps that serve my needs. I got tired of getting used to new/different affordances every few months/years.
vanviegen 2 days ago [-]
> I got tired of getting used to new/different affordances every few months/years.
Have those actually meaningfully changed in the last couple of decades of KDE? If so, I haven't noticed.
exe34 2 days ago [-]
Ah but I went to gnome after kde4 happened. I only use gnome and windows if I'm getting paid for it nowadays.
iberator 2 days ago [-]
same here: left with kde4 and never came back...
I remember using version 1.2 or whatever with AMAZING speed on newer hardware. great memories
mpol 2 days ago [-]
Really great documentary, very much suggested to watch it.
I had no idea Gnome was started without ever talking to the Qt and KDE people. If there was discussion and a solution about the license, the present would be very different I assume. Still, there would be many WMs and DE's, but KDE would be somewhat of a centerpoint.
Also, Aaron Seigo took the criticism of KDE 4 quite hard I would guess. It might be why he is not involved in the project anymore.
WD-42 2 days ago [-]
I’m not sure if you grasp how bad the license situation was. Debian wasn’t even able to ship KDE, like at all. Something had to be done, well beyond “just have a conversation”.
mpol 2 days ago [-]
Well, you need to start with a conversation to find a solution together.
I can understand it to start your own thing, but not even starting a discussion seems a bit immature.
WD-42 2 days ago [-]
Trust me, there were plenty of discussions, and flames, and all kinds of nonsense. QT was the only game in town, so they thought they could use that as leverage on the license issue. Thus, GTK.
F3nd0 2 days ago [-]
Concurrent to GTK, there were also Harmony and GNUstep, right?
noisy_boy 23 hours ago [-]
> Also, Aaron Seigo took the criticism of KDE 4 quite hard I would guess. It might be why he is not involved in the project anymore.
Isn't he the one who built the Plasma foundations that are still holding up the desktop pretty well? Not sure if he is not involved but he is pretty much vindicated by now.
einpoklum 2 days ago [-]
> the present would be very different I assume.
I frankly doubt it. GNOME has pushed many problematic choices which KDE hasn't, or at least hadn't initially. From the anti-usability bent of the UI (few buttons, monochrome over color, non-configurability), to the dependence on systemd, to dropping X in favor of Wayland etc. And this is in part motivated IMHO by the organizational backing for GNOME which is different than KDE.
ahartmetz 2 days ago [-]
Disclaimer: I'm a KDE developer though not super active.
Regarding paid developers, it used to be a few people working for Suse on KDE vs a lot of people working for Red Hat on Gnome. That's not all there is to it because team Gnome also had to maintain GTK and team KDE didn't have to maintain Qt. Gnome had the advantage of having people paid to work on low-level services such as libxml, libdbus and such. AFAIK, today no desktop has many developers paid by distros. You can see it for example on GTK being maintained by like one guy.
Reportedly, external people and companies find KDE is easier to work with than Gnome, and that probably at least played into Valve selecting KDE. Valve's support led to (among other things) KDE having a really really good compositor / window manager. Highly reliable multi-screen support, fractional scaling, high dynamic range, variable refresh rate, frame scheduling for minimum latency (hell yeah), dimming with and without backlight control... a lot of good stuff.
ankurdhama 14 hours ago [-]
But Valve uses their own compositor i.e gamescope for the game mode UI that is the default UI on Steam deck. AFAIK KDE software is only used for desktop mode which is not the main UI of steam deck and more of tool for advance users.
Conan_Kudo 2 days ago [-]
> Regarding paid developers, it used to be a few people working for Suse on KDE vs a lot of people working for Red Hat on Gnome.
There was also Novell/Ximian and Sun Microsystems too. And later on, Canonical did too. All of those companies invested heavily in GNOME alongside Red Hat in the early 2000s.
aeonik 2 days ago [-]
Wow, great job everyone. Love seeing all the faces being the scenes, and the humble beginnings.
I remember the switch to KDE4, and it was indeed brutal. I feel bad that they took as much flak as they did for that.
Plasma has come such a long way, y'all deserve so much for the perseverance and vision.
Thank you for sharing the story!
k0morebi 2 days ago [-]
Been using for over 20 years now. KDE is really the best. Consistent between releases, stable, infinitely customizable, but works great out of the box with features you'd expect and often years ahead of the commercial competition in terms of new features. Every moment I spend in macos or windows for work is pure torture.
pimeys 2 days ago [-]
I used the betas, KDE 1-3, skipped 4 an 5, and I'm now back on the 6 train. It's really nice, and I try to use something else every now and then and I'm back in KDE a few weeks after.
cogman10 2 days ago [-]
5 was a bit rough at the start, but really was pretty nice by the time 6 came around.
6 has been great. If you are a windows or mac user, it's very close to that experience and very familiar.
pimeys 2 days ago [-]
What I really like right now with 6 is the updates: you kind of don't even notice. Things just work better and faster. Your system works the same as yesterday, updates are not a biggie at all.
Can't say the same of Windows or Mac OS.
yonatan8070 2 days ago [-]
I love reading "This week in KDE" on KDE's blog, it's just a cool list of small incremental imrpovements each week, along with credit to MR authors.
I really enjoy that it showcases all the work that goes into making a desktop actually good, even the small things you bearly notice, things like "When a grouped Task Manager task is flashing to get your attention, opening its group popup now reveals which specific window wanted attention. (Christoph Wolk, plasma-desktop MR #4225)"
A change doesn't need to be big and flashy and make headlines, even small changes deserve to be showcased and credited
kombine 1 days ago [-]
> "When a grouped Task Manager task is flashing to get your attention, opening its group popup now reveals which specific window wanted attention. (Christoph Wolk, plasma-desktop MR #4225)"
There's been a proliferation of new desktop environments: Cosmic, Budgie, Hyprland, and so on but it's hundreds of small quality of life features like the one you cited that honestly make Plasma years ahead of the competition.
wolki 2 days ago [-]
Thanks!
And yes, a lot of work goes into the small things.
account42 4 hours ago [-]
That's not at all true. 26.08 outright broke per-directory view settings in Dolphin, on top of removing X11 support from Plasma even though Wayland is still a crapshoot.
cogman10 2 days ago [-]
Oh for sure. Putting KDE linux on some old hardware and it feels like a brand new computer. Updating from windows 8->10->11 on the other hand was always punishing.
It's crazy how slow and bloated windows has become over the years.
k0morebi 2 days ago [-]
I don't remember the earliest version I used, but I vividly remember kde 3.5 and 4 because the transition was really rough. Major regressions and highly disruptive at first, but it laid the groundwork for modern kde and haven't had anything like that since. I jumped ship to gnome out of spite but was back to kde in short order.
pimeys 2 days ago [-]
My earliest memories with KDE was how I was not able to install it because with RedHat 5.0 you needed to download the source code and all the libraries and build it all by yourself.
I asked in the Linux IRC channel some help, gave my root account to a helpful user and very quickly learned about computer security.
iberator 2 days ago [-]
Consistent ?!
KDE was good till version 3.0. Then those all CRAAAAAAZY plasma GUI changes destroyed all fun for me and at some point i didn't understand the GUI itself - didn't know how to use shit(despite using their product for like decade+)
That was pure insanity. No other operating/desktop manager alienized me THAT much.
Gnome2, Kde3, lxde for the win.
szatkus 2 days ago [-]
Feature-wise it's really good, but I wouldn't call it stable. There's a lot of small weird bugs around the environment. Although Mac OS and Windows seem to catching up on that part recently...
~Sent from Firefox on Kubuntu.
SiqingYu 5 hours ago [-]
The coolest thing of Plasma is its capability for customization. You can customize the panels to look like Menu Bar and Dock in MacOS.
Recently got a Macbook Pro for work, and was surprised how archaic MacOS feels compared to KDE. Switching to Linux full-time for personal machines and work has spoiled me.
brabel 1 days ago [-]
I love KDE but to say MacOS feels archaic is the kind of exaggeration you don’t need to reach for to make your point. I use mostly MacOS after many years on KDE because of hardware issues, not the software itself. But KDE has lots of bugs, missing UI features that require running some obscure commands for basic stuff like controlling the trackpad sensitivity settings, which MacOS just doesn’t, given its much bigger user base and development effort.
kevinfiol 1 days ago [-]
I didn't mean it as an exaggeration, only a comparison, but I do feel this way. MacOS is missing so many features that KDE has that I can't believe not having in 2026 on a modern operating system. A lot of these things you can address in MacOS by downloading (or often buying) third party software, or installing a hacky solution. This includes, but is not limited to: a clipboard manager, proper mouse configuration including modifying scroll wheel behavior, enabling audio output on non-Apple monitor speakers, keyboard shortcuts for moving windows between workspaces, phone integration that works with phones that aren't iPhones, window actions and per-app specific window management settings, alt+click to drag, and that's scratching the surface.
At least to me, KDE seems like a desktop environment built for people who use computers. MacOS feels like it's made for people who only use Apple products.
brabel 21 hours ago [-]
Sorry but this is just.... I don't know another word: stupid.
You really think you don't have good ways to do those things on MacOS? What you're saying is essentially that MacOS does not work EXACTLY like KDE, and that's why it's archaic?!
You think people who like computers wouldn't use MacOS? Nearly 80% of developers are on MacOS. You're clearly biases against MacOS and didn't really give it a try if you think like this. I know both OS's well, and I definitely choose MacOS. Not because it's much better, but because I can do absolutely everything I want to, including everything you're claiming to be so hard, and it's the only OS that comes integrated extremely well with the hardware (indisputably, Apple makes the best hardware), so much so that I had to drop my KDE laptop and it hasn't been used in years.
13 hours ago [-]
kevinfiol 13 hours ago [-]
> Sorry but this is just.... I don't know another word: stupid.
OK.
> You really think you don't have good ways to do those things on MacOS?
Yes, some of the things I list are not possible on stock MacOS, require third-party software, or are painful to do. If you're OK dropping cash on things like Rectangle Pro, BetterMouse, BetterTouchTool, or eqMac, you may be fine.
> What you're saying is essentially that MacOS does not work EXACTLY like KDE, and that's why it's archaic?!
I never said that.
Barrin92 19 hours ago [-]
>Nearly 80% of developers are on MacOS
According to last years StackOverflow survey[1], which heavily skews American so if anything disproportionately skews towards Mac, even among that userbase MacOS is far behind Windows and roughly on par with Ubuntu and behind the broader android/linux ecosystem now. So when you've stopped spilling your starbucks latte and pealed the sticker of the macbook at least don't make up numbers wholesale
A over 5 years ago I had to go back to MS Windows from KDE due to change of employer .. I couldn't believe how rubbish Windows was at handling windows!
Win 11 added virtual desktops and drag-drop tile arrangement. They still don't seem to have session restarting with previous window placements (outside PowerToys). Nor do they have keep-above (though it did come back to OneNote).
It still helps primitive to me vs KDE of a decade ago, but that might just be me.
sdwvit 2 days ago [-]
Wonderful quality documentary, just like KDE itself. Really nice to see people behind my favorite software.
moffkalast 2 days ago [-]
I'm so glad KDE exists to take a stand for the power user and customizability, while GNOME sinks ever more into androidification. Like come on, it's a desktop pc with a mouse and keyboard, not a fucking tablet where every icon needs to be 2 miles wide. Without KDE, linux would not be usable as a daily driver for me.
drnick1 1 days ago [-]
> while GNOME sinks ever more into androidification.
GNOME isn't similar to Android at all. The UI very much assumes a keyboard/mouse and can't be easily used as 10-foot TV UI without a remote with an airmouse and keyboard.
snowpid 2 days ago [-]
Its very annoying that some very loud people can not handle the fact that people different have needs. I like to use GNOME. Its fitting me better and dont insult of KDE developers because some people prefer it. The UI systems just have different assumptions and this is just fine.
arzig 2 days ago [-]
I will take the counter point. I think gnomes stance on minimal configuration and a proscribed workflow is commendable. I’m a dev, I see everyday that customization imposes costs.
What I see with gnomes though is that shedding the customization doesn’t actually make for a more solid project. The fact Wayland fractional scale took as long as it did to stabilize despite mostly working tells me gnome didn’t care about the real hardware that makes up the bulk of what exists in the world.
Similarly, it seems like plasma has a massive technical edge just in handling things like pipewire capture, etc. I find KDE is typically smoother and the gnome overview animation almost always stutters regardless of the computer I use it on from discrete gpu desktops down to mobile things.
So I can say that it seems from my experience the gnome project has naval gazed and built a model of the computing landscape they target that is divorced from reality.
I think your defense gets at the difference between a power user and a ricer. They are orthogonal. Gnome rejects ricing. There is one way. That’s fine. I configure stock KDE by changing 2 settings, 1 of which exists in gnome. But I do need to actually do things with my computers which is why the androidification dig hits.
What I will praise unreservedly is the gnome circle apps and broader which are typically polished focused and attractive.
So to me gnome fails at a desktop but has managed to foster a culture around themselves that leads to solid app development.
WD-42 2 days ago [-]
Part of the reason the app development environment is good is because the gnome devs made the correct choice to use C for GTK. Thus there are easy bindings for basically any language.
App development for KDE is still essentially limited to C++ and janky Python.
noisem4ker 2 days ago [-]
You can generally use Qt in Rust with CXX-Qt, and access specific KDE Frameworks modules with cxx-kde-frameworks.
poncho_romero 1 days ago [-]
There are a few programs I am a power user of (browser, terminal, IDE) which I configure heavily for my particular workflows. But beyond that, I really just need a simple, reliable environment, and Gnome provides that for me. I don’t think Gnome’s philosophy is better or worse than KDE’s.
moffkalast 2 days ago [-]
There is some irony in this statement given that GNOME is built on not letting people chose anything and also happens to be the default on Ubuntu, so it's literally force fed down new adopter's throats. It just rubs me the wrong way ideologically so I have to flame them whenever I get the chance.
WD-42 2 days ago [-]
Ignoring the fact that you can write an extension for gnome to make it do whatever you want? Yes there’s less config out of the box, but there’s literally 1000s of extensions will full access to the shells main process. I’m not saying kde is bad, it has more config out of the box, but it is objectively harder to modify if what you need isn’t covered already. Ubuntu ships gnome with pre installed extensions to turn it into the desktop it wants. That would be a nightmare in kde, would require C++ patches, a language fewer and fewer people are willing to touch.
simonask 2 days ago [-]
The fact that you will spend any energy at all “flaming” volunteers donating their time to free software is as baffling as it is cruel.
Though I suppose both Microsoft and Apple are happy to receive your unpaid aid with stuffing their bottom lines.
account42 3 hours ago [-]
Gnome development is largely driven by Red Hat, not "volunteers donating their time".
2III7 2 days ago [-]
I've been using gnome for the past 10 years. Every time I try to use KDE it feels like a wannabe Windows DE, in it's default configuration anyway.
adrian_b 2 days ago [-]
The ancient Windows desktops were quite good so if something tried to emulate them that would be a reasonable goal.
I have no idea how modern KDE is, because I abandoned KDE due to the KDE 4 disaster. Nonetheless, KDE 3.5 was much better than Windows XP, even if its default configuration was somewhat similar.
Actually I consider KDE 3.5 the best desktop environment that I have ever seen, much better not only than the contemporaneous Windows XP, but also than the contemporaneous Mac OS X. The reason was that KDE 3.5 had an extreme customizability, so everyone could reconfigure it according to their tastes, so it no longer resembled any other desktop environment. Unfortunately, almost everything that I liked in KDE 3.5 was removed in KDE 4 and replaced with rigid choices that I disliked.
After KDE 4, I never had the courage to try KDE again (I fled to the refuge of XFCE), but I hope that it has recovered and now it is at least at the level of its past glory, if not better.
bityard 2 days ago [-]
KDE finally got back to its 3.x level of quality a few years back, towards the middle of the 5.x releases. They are now on 6.x.
I highly recommend giving it another try, I'm super picky and modern KDE simply delivers the best and most flexible desktop experience, bar none.
pimeys 2 days ago [-]
Yep. I used KDE from the early betas until KDE 4 and escaped at that point to the i3/sway world.
KDE 6 is really good tho. It's so fast, works great, Dolphin is the absolute best file manager there is...
blooalien 2 days ago [-]
> ... because I abandoned KDE due to the KDE 4 disaster.
I totally hated that whole mess. It almost ruined KDE for me. The real disaster there wasn't that KDE released v4 prematurely, but that they didn't make it crystal clear to the distro maintainers (and end-users) that it was not ready for "prime time" use yet (it was basically "pre-release"/alpha quality), and the major distros of the time jumped on making it the default (forced it on everyone) when it was still basically utterly broken compared to the prior versions of KDE (which had become overall quite solid and reliable by that point).
toyg 2 days ago [-]
It's all post-hoc rationalisation. They got caught in their own hype and released low-quality code. They fucked up, that's all, and it's a bit embarrassing that they won't admit it.
pimeys 2 days ago [-]
But also they built on it, and KDE 6 benefits from all that work and is an exceptional desktop.
moffkalast 2 days ago [-]
Yeah KDE mimics Windows, Cinnamon mimics MacOS, and GNOME mimics Android. That's sort of the intention, so you can keep your workflow.
tredre3 2 days ago [-]
Cinnamon definitely mimics classic Windows... That's essentially its entire point.
GNOME is the mishmash of macos and, like you said, mobile design.
moffkalast 2 days ago [-]
Hmm I swear I saw the exact same MacOS minimize/maximize/close buttons and on the left in Cinnamon at one point, but now that I'm looking up the latest screenshots it seems to be the usual. Maybe it was some specific distro only?
ThePinion 2 days ago [-]
Ubuntu had the window controls on the left side from like 2010-2017 to go along with their Unity desktop. From what I recall, this has always been an option with Cinnamon but they default it to the right side.
lunar_rover 2 days ago [-]
Nothing on Linux mimics macOS aside from surface level things like caption button placement and global menu.
Actually nothing mimics Windows either. Linux desktop almost completely missed the biggest desktop UX advancements happened in late 2000s.
adrian_b 1 days ago [-]
Which are those?
In the distant past, I liked the Windows UI, despite the fact that I have never seen any Windows program with a user interface as optimized for high productivity as a few of the MS-DOS programs had, even if they were restricted to the much inferior hardware of that time.
But in the last decade, whenever I had to use Windows for work related purposes I found that very unpleasant, as I felt like in a straitjacket in comparison with what I can do in Linux, when configured how I like it. To be fair, there are Linux distributions whose default configurations feel equally unpleasant for me as Windows, e.g. Ubuntu, because I do not like any default desktop configuration that I have encountered, and the unpleasantness happens when I cannot change the configuration according to my taste.
If there have been any UX innovations done after 2000, they are very well hidden because I have never seen anyone using such an innovation.
lunar_rover 19 hours ago [-]
Polish and general design philosophy, a million small steps.
Explorer from Windows Vista onwards has the best sorting, grouping and filtering experience even today, same with Windows 8 Task Manager. You can't configure them into existence unless you write your own apps.
HIGs of the two biggest Linux desktops both flaunt harmful principles around, either by focusing on simplicity exclusively or by implying a dichotomy between power and simplicity that's almost always false. Microsoft still has the Aero guidelines on their site: https://learn.microsoft.com/windows/win32/uxguide/how-to-des...
pimeys 2 days ago [-]
And Windows mimics KDE. It's a loop.
brabel 1 days ago [-]
I wonder if anything MSFT did really took inspiration from KDE. I would think that is very highly improbable.
noisem4ker 21 hours ago [-]
They for sure took the "Simple by default, powerful when needed" motto, and the Maui name for their toolkit.
At least Windows got all the following after KDE (though not saying that KDE invented them):
* Composting with transparent windows
* Alt+TAB and task bar previews for window contents
* Soft-tiling by dragging windows to desktop borders
flyerbird 2 days ago [-]
Their story is inspirational; if this were a commercial project, they would surely have taken over the market. Hearing about the challenges they faced with Qt, and how their HTML engine was adopted by Apple, is so interesting.
KDE deserves a lot more.
win95 2 days ago [-]
Btw it's also on youtube, just search KDE documentary. I've also watched other documentaries from this channel and this KDE one stands out.
ReDress 1 days ago [-]
[dead]
noisy_boy 23 hours ago [-]
I am just amazed how well designed the Plasma foundations must be for them to be holding strong for so many years. Incredibly impressive.
anotherevan 2 days ago [-]
I must have used KDE for close on two decades, from the 3.x days onwards. I seem to remember I ran Suse for a long time as it seemed to be the best distro for using with KDE.
About eight years ago I wanted to try a tiling window manager, ended up settling on Awesomewm and still with it today, but I still use Dolphin as I've found no other file manager compares. (Or maybe I'm just too comfortable with it to change.)
Also still use Konsole, but honestly, as soon as Ghostty or similar implement being able to switch tabs in MRU order instead of round-robin I'll jump.
I have a low-priority todo to give Cosmic, Hyprland and Niri a go at some point. Would be nice to go back into a fuller desktop experience over what I've cobbled together around "just" a window manager.
It's a new terminal emulator for KDE built on libghostty-vt. Konsole is so incredibly mature and solid, but this has a chance of replacing it.
ddtaylor 1 days ago [-]
Big shout out to Harald Sitter at KDE.
I'm a long-time contributor to KDE, but my contributions are small and often times required jumping into a completely different project each time. Combine that with some of it being Qt related and how those libraries are linked and it can be a bit painful sometimes. Herald helps with this kind of stuff and provides a lot of very useful amplification where a minute of his time ripples out into many fixes and merges.
mikemcquaid 1 days ago [-]
KDE is how I got started in OSS (GSoC 2007). Without it I doubt Homebrew or GitHub Sponsors would be the same. All in on macOS nowadays so so lovely to see KDE keeps shipping.
madisp 2 days ago [-]
I recently switched to KDE on my main workstation and it has been such a breath fresh air. I can't exactly put my finger on it, but the mix between aesthetics, configurability and a bit of pre-2010s UX design is really good.
elendilm 2 days ago [-]
It is very hard to imagine what life would be without the awesomeness that KDE is.
simgt 1 days ago [-]
I really enjoyed this, the contributors seem to really like having worked together for all this time. I wish they had gone a bit more into the details of the governance and how they managed to resolve the unavoidable conflicts.
CrLf 2 days ago [-]
In a documentary about KDE, it's interesting how many (most) of the people shown using a computer are running macOS...
account42 3 hours ago [-]
Intresting is not the word I would use. Perhaps "frightening" would be closer.
rodolphoarruda 2 days ago [-]
That was my comment. It seems that they use MacOS as their primary system and have KDE running in VMs as "projects".
When I switched to Linux in 2008 (Ubuntu), I felt a big relief from not using Windows anymore, andnever turned back.
sho_hn 2 days ago [-]
It's a bit different.
KDE has really seen about 3-4 generations of contributors at this point. The docu is very much the origin story, so you see some of the very original, initial contributors in it. Some of them haven't been active in over 20 years now.
Most of them were students when they did their contributions (as you saw, KDE got going around Uni Tübingen before quickly going international), and a lot of them stopped working on KDE when they got a "real job" and life took them into other directions. The Linux desktop was far less established back then, and a lot of them probably had to use other systems for work and stuck with them. On some level, they didn't get to reap the benefits of what they had sown themselves.
KDE's active contributors certainly use KDE Plasma on their laptops, and it's rare to see any MacBooks at our events (and if you do, it's typically running Asahi). I can't really think of anyone who does the VM thing.
And even the ones who don't do KDE stuff at their dayjobs probably get to use KDE at work (e.g. I work at Mercedes-Benz, where the default Linux developer laptop runs KDE Plasma). This is still to the credit of those original contributors.
pjmlp 2 hours ago [-]
As someone that started into Linux in 1995, have used plenty of UNIX systems, eventually it gets tiresome to buy laptops where there is always some hurdle, and getting from Tuxedo/System 76 and co, also has their own surprises.
So I get Windows with whatever VM solution on top, VMWare, Virtual Box, nowadays WSL and move on.
Or get assigned a macbook in some projects, get my UNIX tools, and move on as well.
Additionally there is some server I can ssh into just like in the old days when everyone was using development servers for the whole team with thin clients.
praseodym 2 days ago [-]
Maybe some of those original developers have just moved on to new jobs and projects?
ulimn 2 days ago [-]
I was also surprised to see that they use Macbooks. I also have one but I find it a weird decision to showcase in a documentary about KDE.
Kudos to the guy with the Dell(?) laptop in the video. :)
3 hours ago [-]
4thguy 21 hours ago [-]
"doKumentary" was right there
pelagicAustral 2 days ago [-]
I wish I could have a DE that looks like KDE 3 or before...
Other distros bundle TDE, not just Q4OS, but it is not a bad one and a quick way to try it.
Klassik is very new and as yet quite untested.
Me, I would like the original KDE fork used in Corel LinuxOS and later in Xandros Linux to be revived and modernised. For me that was the best KDE ever worked.
(The Bluecurve theme in Red Hat Linux -- before RH _Enterprise_ Linux -- was the best mainline KDE ever looked.)
blooalien 2 days ago [-]
> I wish I could have a DE that looks like KDE 3 or before...
You probably want Trinity DE then. It's literally KDE 3, forked and maintained.
kmac_ 1 days ago [-]
KDE user here. It's fast, it's ergonomic, it's modern, it's stable, and the defaults are great. I use it on 3 different machines, at work and at home. Big thank you to the team!
jordanarseno 2 days ago [-]
A great way to start my morning, thank you for posting
ElijahLynn 2 days ago [-]
I just watched the first 2 minutes and I didn't even know it stood for Cool Desktop Environment initially. And then it turned to KDE because they didn't want to use CDE.
At any rate, I'm busy right now, but I'm hooked and, and totally going to watch this. Thanks for posting it.
ahartmetz 2 days ago [-]
AFAIU, "can't start with C" was not an afterthought. It was explicitly meant to be the anti-CDE, something better to prevent the clunky and non-free CDE from becoming the default DE on Linux.
(I actually somewhat like the look of Motif, CDE's toolkit. It is maybe the association with reliable, expensive, professional (etc) Unix application software. While proprietary, still much cooler than Windows.)
ladyanita22 2 days ago [-]
I wonder if it was edited in Kdenlive
dvirsky 1 days ago [-]
While I enjoy the productivity boost of AI coding for my work as much as the next guy, it makes me sad to think that this way of producing software is gone forever.
All the way from there to the Steam Deck and for the last month on the Steam Frame, using KDE in VR. Amazing.
solveproblemswi 2 days ago [-]
Never new about the origin story. Really fun watch.
academicfish 2 days ago [-]
A big KDE fan here, and it's awesome to see real faces behind the project.
int32max 1 days ago [-]
love kde and first time trying out kockatoo which looks cool !
einpoklum 2 days ago [-]
What is the country-of-residence distribution of KDE contributors? Originally, and today? Judging from the film, it seems like a lot of people from Germany and Finland (maybe other Scandinavian countries); but maybe it's just the documentary availability bias + my memory bias?
WD-42 2 days ago [-]
Kde has always leaned European and gnome the Americas.
Taniwha 2 days ago [-]
All over the world, I was an early KDE dev from the US at the time
shevy-java 1 days ago [-]
They seem to talk about the whole history of KDE.
I don't think this works well. For instance, KDE back in 2006 or
2007, give or take, was very different to KDE in 2026. Not only
because older people tend to retire (or die), and younger people
follow up, but also because of policy changes and different people
pushing through with their ideas. Back in 2006, you would not be able
to find someone like Nate who wants to push a donation-daemon into
KDE. Fast forward and suddenly you have that. You also have people
wanting to add a dependency on systemd (David Edmundson) - lo and
behold, that is suddenly happening. I could bring more examples,
but I feel that it is unfair to claim xyz at this point in time, is
KDE or how KDE always used to be. That's simply not the case. It is
no the case with GNOME either; see why mate-desktop was forked when
people did not want to transition into a smartphone-centric UI (though
there is no real way around that with GTK5 eventually, since it will
be wayland-locked-down only).
So these videos are just happy-go-lucky. That's IMO very bad.
I'd much prefer a style such as in the old movie manufacturing consent.
Now, the movie also had various issues and is also quite outdated now,
but at the least you'd have a SLIGHTLY more balanced view rather than
just a promo-video, which this video is ultimately about.
Edit: mongol shared a somewhat similar criticism; not about the above
mentioned content, but with regards to KDE 4 and the promo-video totally
ignoring that fact. Well, this is a sunshine-video. It has no real
substance indeed so I concur with mongol on that part.
I also agree with iberator, though I was never that much a DE user per se.
I did use KDE 3.x, naturally 4.x was a dead end, but already before that I
transitioned into fluxbox. From a workflow-centric approach, I found fluxbox to
be so much more productive than KDE. I would use KDE konsole on fluxbox, though,
as it is a great terminal. okular is also ok-ish, though I found evince to be
snappier and faster, so I use that for .pdf files usually (okular is more
feature-rich though). Most other KDE programs I don't really need; I do most
actions via KDE konsole and scripts.
The_President 23 hours ago [-]
Big fan of KDE, but little issues like the direction taken in regards to depricating ksysguard ("speghetti code") in favor of the slow plasma-systemmonitor application, all while the bluetooth implementation is half baked and krunner is laggy, is disappointing. One of the best daily desktop environments but with a history of minor priority issues.
account42 3 hours ago [-]
Yeah, its a shame how some people feel the need to take over existing OSS projects to enforce their views on the established userbase rathern than gaining users for their way of doing things by convincing them that it is actually better.
zer0zzz 1 days ago [-]
Amusing how the shots of miguel's terminal all show him coding in Swift on a mac
shmerl 2 days ago [-]
It's interesting that KDE originally stands for Kool Desktop Environment as the video mentions.
vlowrian 2 days ago [-]
I've become a big fan of CultRepo's documentaries. If you enjoyed this one, I highly recommend checking out their catalogue of free, high-quality content (https://www.cultrepo.com/films).
They cover a wide range of topics, from C++ and Java to Node.js, Kubernetes, React, and Vue.js. I particularly enjoyed the Java documentary, which offered fascinating insights into the differences between the Sun and Oracle eras, many of which I never would have expected.
sick_of_slop 2 days ago [-]
I was a Gnome guy since the 16.04 Ubuntu days even with the transition to 3 and whatnot. Stopped using a linux desktop for a while but came back and used CachyOS - when deciding what desktop to use, everyone online said KDE so I gave it a shot and haven't look back since.
A few times I had to do something on a Gnome system and now it just feels like you're being kneecapped by the devs for no good reason.
tuna74 2 days ago [-]
How do you know if someone does not like Gnome?
Don't worry, they will talk about not liking Gnome even when the topic is something completely different.
Thank you KDE folks - I contribute in terms of bug reports and attempts at fixes sometimes but this time I am signing up for a monthly donation - I encourage people to do what they can to keep a good thing going! https://kde.org/donate/
A week ago I bought a cheap mini-htpc and put Plasma Bigscreen on it, using a phone with KDEconnect as remote. So easy to use! So much better than AndroidTV let alone proprietary crap.
KDE is just great.
Connect, KdenLive, Krita, KFind and a whole bunch of other stuff is very useful.
Does KDE Connect cover some of the usefulness of Tailscale?
Congratulations, team. Here's to 30 more years.
Really genuinely glad you found the thing that works for you (and that your company accommodated it), that’s what matters.
Last I looked at KDE was some two decades ago and didn’t like it visually, but since then I’ve been curious to give it another shot.
I've stuck to Ubuntu since it's what I learned about the first during university, but I unfortunately notice that Ubuntu 26.04 is by far the least polished Ubuntu version I've ever used, so I'm inclined to do the switch.
Linux life, yo.
I feel the documentary explains less what happened the last 10-15 years. I recall Trolltech and Qt underwent a series of acquisitions. How is KDE and Qt developed now? Who are the main contributors and sponsors? Any big backers? This information I felt missing.
Qt is now its own company, namely Qt Group. Wikipedia quotes:
> In 2018, the company had 5,000 customers. Approximately 80% of the Fortune 500 companies are customers of Qt Group.[22]
So it's self-sustaining now.
AFAIK, KDE is still mostly volunteer work, but the way they develop software is pretty robust.
Currently I fail to see big problems while I daily drive this thing, but mine might be a bias, of course.
However, KDE rocks. My colleagues called me "a maniac" once when they see how I use that thing (i.e. Dolphin + KIO + fast window switches + multiple desktops).
The KDE4 days were rough, by then I had jumped over to fedora, and that one didn't shy away from shipping very early and unstable versions of it. That had me hopping for alternative DEs, I seriously tried several (and stuck for a while with some) of the minimalistic ones (enlightenment, XFCE, ...) and quickly ended up depending on either KWin, and/or some battery/networking/disks applet from plasma, or configuring something via systemsettings. The plasma desktop itself is fine (I don't mind it so much, I'm not crazy about shell theming and customisations, I do love my global menu on top, though), but what sells KDE for me is all the clever ancillary stuff that makes it "smart and usable" (dealing with Bluetooth, network setup, local and remote drives, audio output, ...), that's where the "environment" metaphor kicks in and elevates the experience above that of a "desktop shell".
Back then whenever I had a chance to try a distro with KDE 4, the Crash Handler window would pop after doing stupidest and simplest things within the desktop. Gnome 3 wasn't any better - it was more stable but departing from desktop metaphor to this mobile-desktop hybrid made me avoid it and pick Xfce instead. Which is shame because KDE4 despite the problems looked really well (and still does); I once said here that it had this "younger sister of Vista's Aero" vibe. It's really cool that they managed to bring Oxygen theme back.
Have those actually meaningfully changed in the last couple of decades of KDE? If so, I haven't noticed.
I remember using version 1.2 or whatever with AMAZING speed on newer hardware. great memories
I had no idea Gnome was started without ever talking to the Qt and KDE people. If there was discussion and a solution about the license, the present would be very different I assume. Still, there would be many WMs and DE's, but KDE would be somewhat of a centerpoint.
Also, Aaron Seigo took the criticism of KDE 4 quite hard I would guess. It might be why he is not involved in the project anymore.
I can understand it to start your own thing, but not even starting a discussion seems a bit immature.
Isn't he the one who built the Plasma foundations that are still holding up the desktop pretty well? Not sure if he is not involved but he is pretty much vindicated by now.
I frankly doubt it. GNOME has pushed many problematic choices which KDE hasn't, or at least hadn't initially. From the anti-usability bent of the UI (few buttons, monochrome over color, non-configurability), to the dependence on systemd, to dropping X in favor of Wayland etc. And this is in part motivated IMHO by the organizational backing for GNOME which is different than KDE.
Regarding paid developers, it used to be a few people working for Suse on KDE vs a lot of people working for Red Hat on Gnome. That's not all there is to it because team Gnome also had to maintain GTK and team KDE didn't have to maintain Qt. Gnome had the advantage of having people paid to work on low-level services such as libxml, libdbus and such. AFAIK, today no desktop has many developers paid by distros. You can see it for example on GTK being maintained by like one guy.
Reportedly, external people and companies find KDE is easier to work with than Gnome, and that probably at least played into Valve selecting KDE. Valve's support led to (among other things) KDE having a really really good compositor / window manager. Highly reliable multi-screen support, fractional scaling, high dynamic range, variable refresh rate, frame scheduling for minimum latency (hell yeah), dimming with and without backlight control... a lot of good stuff.
There was also Novell/Ximian and Sun Microsystems too. And later on, Canonical did too. All of those companies invested heavily in GNOME alongside Red Hat in the early 2000s.
I remember the switch to KDE4, and it was indeed brutal. I feel bad that they took as much flak as they did for that.
Plasma has come such a long way, y'all deserve so much for the perseverance and vision.
Thank you for sharing the story!
6 has been great. If you are a windows or mac user, it's very close to that experience and very familiar.
Can't say the same of Windows or Mac OS.
I really enjoy that it showcases all the work that goes into making a desktop actually good, even the small things you bearly notice, things like "When a grouped Task Manager task is flashing to get your attention, opening its group popup now reveals which specific window wanted attention. (Christoph Wolk, plasma-desktop MR #4225)"
A change doesn't need to be big and flashy and make headlines, even small changes deserve to be showcased and credited
There's been a proliferation of new desktop environments: Cosmic, Budgie, Hyprland, and so on but it's hundreds of small quality of life features like the one you cited that honestly make Plasma years ahead of the competition.
And yes, a lot of work goes into the small things.
It's crazy how slow and bloated windows has become over the years.
I asked in the Linux IRC channel some help, gave my root account to a helpful user and very quickly learned about computer security.
KDE was good till version 3.0. Then those all CRAAAAAAZY plasma GUI changes destroyed all fun for me and at some point i didn't understand the GUI itself - didn't know how to use shit(despite using their product for like decade+)
That was pure insanity. No other operating/desktop manager alienized me THAT much.
Gnome2, Kde3, lxde for the win.
~Sent from Firefox on Kubuntu.
One particular good community widget is Panel Colorizer (https://github.com/luisbocanegra/plasma-panel-colorizer), which makes the panels look even more gorgeous.
At least to me, KDE seems like a desktop environment built for people who use computers. MacOS feels like it's made for people who only use Apple products.
OK.
> You really think you don't have good ways to do those things on MacOS?
Yes, some of the things I list are not possible on stock MacOS, require third-party software, or are painful to do. If you're OK dropping cash on things like Rectangle Pro, BetterMouse, BetterTouchTool, or eqMac, you may be fine.
> What you're saying is essentially that MacOS does not work EXACTLY like KDE, and that's why it's archaic?!
I never said that.
According to last years StackOverflow survey[1], which heavily skews American so if anything disproportionately skews towards Mac, even among that userbase MacOS is far behind Windows and roughly on par with Ubuntu and behind the broader android/linux ecosystem now. So when you've stopped spilling your starbucks latte and pealed the sticker of the macbook at least don't make up numbers wholesale
[1]https://survey.stackoverflow.co/2025/technology#1-computer-o...
Win 11 added virtual desktops and drag-drop tile arrangement. They still don't seem to have session restarting with previous window placements (outside PowerToys). Nor do they have keep-above (though it did come back to OneNote).
It still helps primitive to me vs KDE of a decade ago, but that might just be me.
GNOME isn't similar to Android at all. The UI very much assumes a keyboard/mouse and can't be easily used as 10-foot TV UI without a remote with an airmouse and keyboard.
What I see with gnomes though is that shedding the customization doesn’t actually make for a more solid project. The fact Wayland fractional scale took as long as it did to stabilize despite mostly working tells me gnome didn’t care about the real hardware that makes up the bulk of what exists in the world.
Similarly, it seems like plasma has a massive technical edge just in handling things like pipewire capture, etc. I find KDE is typically smoother and the gnome overview animation almost always stutters regardless of the computer I use it on from discrete gpu desktops down to mobile things.
So I can say that it seems from my experience the gnome project has naval gazed and built a model of the computing landscape they target that is divorced from reality.
I think your defense gets at the difference between a power user and a ricer. They are orthogonal. Gnome rejects ricing. There is one way. That’s fine. I configure stock KDE by changing 2 settings, 1 of which exists in gnome. But I do need to actually do things with my computers which is why the androidification dig hits.
What I will praise unreservedly is the gnome circle apps and broader which are typically polished focused and attractive.
So to me gnome fails at a desktop but has managed to foster a culture around themselves that leads to solid app development.
App development for KDE is still essentially limited to C++ and janky Python.
Though I suppose both Microsoft and Apple are happy to receive your unpaid aid with stuffing their bottom lines.
I have no idea how modern KDE is, because I abandoned KDE due to the KDE 4 disaster. Nonetheless, KDE 3.5 was much better than Windows XP, even if its default configuration was somewhat similar.
Actually I consider KDE 3.5 the best desktop environment that I have ever seen, much better not only than the contemporaneous Windows XP, but also than the contemporaneous Mac OS X. The reason was that KDE 3.5 had an extreme customizability, so everyone could reconfigure it according to their tastes, so it no longer resembled any other desktop environment. Unfortunately, almost everything that I liked in KDE 3.5 was removed in KDE 4 and replaced with rigid choices that I disliked.
After KDE 4, I never had the courage to try KDE again (I fled to the refuge of XFCE), but I hope that it has recovered and now it is at least at the level of its past glory, if not better.
I highly recommend giving it another try, I'm super picky and modern KDE simply delivers the best and most flexible desktop experience, bar none.
KDE 6 is really good tho. It's so fast, works great, Dolphin is the absolute best file manager there is...
I totally hated that whole mess. It almost ruined KDE for me. The real disaster there wasn't that KDE released v4 prematurely, but that they didn't make it crystal clear to the distro maintainers (and end-users) that it was not ready for "prime time" use yet (it was basically "pre-release"/alpha quality), and the major distros of the time jumped on making it the default (forced it on everyone) when it was still basically utterly broken compared to the prior versions of KDE (which had become overall quite solid and reliable by that point).
GNOME is the mishmash of macos and, like you said, mobile design.
Actually nothing mimics Windows either. Linux desktop almost completely missed the biggest desktop UX advancements happened in late 2000s.
In the distant past, I liked the Windows UI, despite the fact that I have never seen any Windows program with a user interface as optimized for high productivity as a few of the MS-DOS programs had, even if they were restricted to the much inferior hardware of that time.
But in the last decade, whenever I had to use Windows for work related purposes I found that very unpleasant, as I felt like in a straitjacket in comparison with what I can do in Linux, when configured how I like it. To be fair, there are Linux distributions whose default configurations feel equally unpleasant for me as Windows, e.g. Ubuntu, because I do not like any default desktop configuration that I have encountered, and the unpleasantness happens when I cannot change the configuration according to my taste.
If there have been any UX innovations done after 2000, they are very well hidden because I have never seen anyone using such an innovation.
Explorer from Windows Vista onwards has the best sorting, grouping and filtering experience even today, same with Windows 8 Task Manager. You can't configure them into existence unless you write your own apps.
HIGs of the two biggest Linux desktops both flaunt harmful principles around, either by focusing on simplicity exclusively or by implying a dichotomy between power and simplicity that's almost always false. Microsoft still has the Aero guidelines on their site: https://learn.microsoft.com/windows/win32/uxguide/how-to-des...
[1] https://x.com/claucambra/status/1466153819713191947
[2] https://gearwisdom.blog/microsoft-vs-kde-maui-trademark-disp...
* Composting with transparent windows
* Alt+TAB and task bar previews for window contents
* Soft-tiling by dragging windows to desktop borders
KDE deserves a lot more.
About eight years ago I wanted to try a tiling window manager, ended up settling on Awesomewm and still with it today, but I still use Dolphin as I've found no other file manager compares. (Or maybe I'm just too comfortable with it to change.)
Also still use Konsole, but honestly, as soon as Ghostty or similar implement being able to switch tabs in MRU order instead of round-robin I'll jump.
I have a low-priority todo to give Cosmic, Hyprland and Niri a go at some point. Would be nice to go back into a fuller desktop experience over what I've cobbled together around "just" a window manager.
It's a new terminal emulator for KDE built on libghostty-vt. Konsole is so incredibly mature and solid, but this has a chance of replacing it.
I'm a long-time contributor to KDE, but my contributions are small and often times required jumping into a completely different project each time. Combine that with some of it being Qt related and how those libraries are linked and it can be a bit painful sometimes. Herald helps with this kind of stuff and provides a lot of very useful amplification where a minute of his time ripples out into many fixes and merges.
When I switched to Linux in 2008 (Ubuntu), I felt a big relief from not using Windows anymore, andnever turned back.
KDE has really seen about 3-4 generations of contributors at this point. The docu is very much the origin story, so you see some of the very original, initial contributors in it. Some of them haven't been active in over 20 years now.
Most of them were students when they did their contributions (as you saw, KDE got going around Uni Tübingen before quickly going international), and a lot of them stopped working on KDE when they got a "real job" and life took them into other directions. The Linux desktop was far less established back then, and a lot of them probably had to use other systems for work and stuck with them. On some level, they didn't get to reap the benefits of what they had sown themselves.
KDE's active contributors certainly use KDE Plasma on their laptops, and it's rare to see any MacBooks at our events (and if you do, it's typically running Asahi). I can't really think of anyone who does the VM thing.
And even the ones who don't do KDE stuff at their dayjobs probably get to use KDE at work (e.g. I work at Mercedes-Benz, where the default Linux developer laptop runs KDE Plasma). This is still to the credit of those original contributors.
So I get Windows with whatever VM solution on top, VMWare, Virtual Box, nowadays WSL and move on.
Or get assigned a macbook in some projects, get my UNIX tools, and move on as well.
Additionally there is some server I can ssh into just like in the old days when everyone was using development servers for the whole team with thin clients.
Kudos to the guy with the Dell(?) laptop in the video. :)
Want a whole new desktop?
https://www.trinitydesktop.org/
Want a whole new OS with it built in?
https://q4os.org/
Want to keep the KDE 6.x foundations but replace the desktop shell?
https://github.com/neeeeow/Klassik
Other distros bundle TDE, not just Q4OS, but it is not a bad one and a quick way to try it.
Klassik is very new and as yet quite untested.
Me, I would like the original KDE fork used in Corel LinuxOS and later in Xandros Linux to be revived and modernised. For me that was the best KDE ever worked.
(The Bluecurve theme in Red Hat Linux -- before RH _Enterprise_ Linux -- was the best mainline KDE ever looked.)
You probably want Trinity DE then. It's literally KDE 3, forked and maintained.
At any rate, I'm busy right now, but I'm hooked and, and totally going to watch this. Thanks for posting it.
(I actually somewhat like the look of Motif, CDE's toolkit. It is maybe the association with reliable, expensive, professional (etc) Unix application software. While proprietary, still much cooler than Windows.)
1 month ago
I don't think this works well. For instance, KDE back in 2006 or 2007, give or take, was very different to KDE in 2026. Not only because older people tend to retire (or die), and younger people follow up, but also because of policy changes and different people pushing through with their ideas. Back in 2006, you would not be able to find someone like Nate who wants to push a donation-daemon into KDE. Fast forward and suddenly you have that. You also have people wanting to add a dependency on systemd (David Edmundson) - lo and behold, that is suddenly happening. I could bring more examples, but I feel that it is unfair to claim xyz at this point in time, is KDE or how KDE always used to be. That's simply not the case. It is no the case with GNOME either; see why mate-desktop was forked when people did not want to transition into a smartphone-centric UI (though there is no real way around that with GTK5 eventually, since it will be wayland-locked-down only).
So these videos are just happy-go-lucky. That's IMO very bad.
I'd much prefer a style such as in the old movie manufacturing consent. Now, the movie also had various issues and is also quite outdated now, but at the least you'd have a SLIGHTLY more balanced view rather than just a promo-video, which this video is ultimately about.
Edit: mongol shared a somewhat similar criticism; not about the above mentioned content, but with regards to KDE 4 and the promo-video totally ignoring that fact. Well, this is a sunshine-video. It has no real substance indeed so I concur with mongol on that part.
I also agree with iberator, though I was never that much a DE user per se. I did use KDE 3.x, naturally 4.x was a dead end, but already before that I transitioned into fluxbox. From a workflow-centric approach, I found fluxbox to be so much more productive than KDE. I would use KDE konsole on fluxbox, though, as it is a great terminal. okular is also ok-ish, though I found evince to be snappier and faster, so I use that for .pdf files usually (okular is more feature-rich though). Most other KDE programs I don't really need; I do most actions via KDE konsole and scripts.
They cover a wide range of topics, from C++ and Java to Node.js, Kubernetes, React, and Vue.js. I particularly enjoyed the Java documentary, which offered fascinating insights into the differences between the Sun and Oracle eras, many of which I never would have expected.
A few times I had to do something on a Gnome system and now it just feels like you're being kneecapped by the devs for no good reason.
Don't worry, they will talk about not liking Gnome even when the topic is something completely different.