Rendered at 18:40:30 GMT+0000 (Coordinated Universal Time) with Cloudflare Workers.
elevation 5 hours ago [-]
You don't fight wars for the fun of fighting, you have tactical objectives.
If your nation only survives the winter because of a supply of grain and heating oil, then any threat that cuts off those supplies will kill you eventually. Often economic solutions suffice, but if you must protect yourself by kinetic means, then the battlefield is determined by the location (and supply lines) of the threat.
bluGill 4 hours ago [-]
Plenty of analysts have examined the WWII tactics Germany used so well at the start and concluded they were very very risky and just some minor changes to French tactics would have defeated them (but at a different cost - France would have had to abandon allies to get the troops in the right place, even though the war would have looked different we would be picking on the France for that dishonorable action today)
That is the problem with history. We can see what worked and didn't work. We can't nearly as easially know what is luck and what is good strategy/tactics. Many commenters talk about the current war as if everything changes, but it is never clear what is a major change and what is a blip that works now but soon be countered.
rdtsc 5 hours ago [-]
> The attacking Russians, who have no holes to sit in, no cities to shelter in, and can neither concentrate nor achieve surprise, are suffering astonishing losses
But it still doesn’t bother them too much. Consider that they haven’t even started a full mobilization yet. They just keep sending groups of soldiers who then get droned, send another and so on. Eventually a few get through, so it’s a slowly advancing front.
ceejayoz 5 hours ago [-]
> Consider that they haven’t even started a full mobilization yet.
Can they? I'm inclined to see "we're not really trying yet" as cope, especially this far in.
> Eventually a few get through, so it’s a slowly advancing front.
It's true that Kremlin has reasons to avoid obligatory mobilization for reasons which go beyond military practicalites as it would probably be a public humiliation for them both at home and internationally. But they have lots of poor people raised in collectivist culture whose lives can be bought and sacrificed with equivalent of $20000, and they have deep coffers from selling oil, and gas.
And their bet is very likely on the West surrendering soon enough due to its political instability, and stopping support to Ukraine. So speed, or even direction of front-line changes could be a secondary concern for them as long as this expectation is valid. They need just enough cannon fodder to prolong the war.
Things like "diesel deal", or pro-Russian statements of AfD, BSW and the likes certainly reinforce them in belief that it is valid. Also they probably pay, and influence (same way as USSR did) pundits, and politicians to make it happen. Taken as whole it looks like a strategy.
ceejayoz 4 hours ago [-]
They have more challenges than plain old humiliation.
Something like 1 in 25 of Russian men have been killed or wounded in the war, in a country that was already aging and below replacement levels.
I don't deny Russia's trying to outlast Ukraine and the West, but I'm not sure broad mobilization is even possible.
rdtsc 3 hours ago [-]
> Can they? I'm inclined to see "we're not really trying yet" as cope, especially this far in.
As in, can they issue the decree? Absolutely. Would it lead to the regime toppling, possibly, as well. I am mainly going by the number of people they are sending in the meat grinder. They don't act like they are caring that much for them. It's a bit hard to fight with an enemy like that. But I think it's a bit hard to deny that they simply have more people to grind than Ukraine does. That's kind what Russians are hoping for, just grind down the Ukrainian manpower. The rest of the world is hoping for Putin to die and get a regime change, I think.
myrmidon 3 hours ago [-]
The grind down thing only really works if you "out-ratio" them, though.
Russian population is not that much bigger (times 3-4 or so), and they can expect both higher losses (as attacker) and less willingness to sacrifice the same fraction of their population (because the war is existential for Ukraine but not for them).
So that approach might be doomed already; even if feasible numerically the margins should be pretty small.
rdtsc 2 hours ago [-]
> Russian population is not that much bigger (times 3-4 or so)
It depends on absolute numbers too. If it's 1M vs 3M probably not a huge deal but we're talking 140M vs 40M, so that's 100M more. Obviously the majority won't be good for fighting. Going by the numbers they are willing throw into the grinder daily they don't act like a side that feels the constraints too badly, yet.
> because the war is existential for Ukraine but not for them
Agree, that's a good point. But it also matters how many men are left on the Ukraine's side who feel like they'd want to fight the existential battle. That's not resource that's infinite even if we assume the highest levels of patriotism and duty.
I am not sure how this conflict will end. It seems unlikely one side will be able just plow through and collapse the front enemy lines any time soon or ever. For Ukraine, at this point, they'd probably need some huge swarms of jam proof autonomous drones that can with a single operator cover 10s of sq kilometers.
myrmidon 35 minutes ago [-]
The only advantage that absolute numbers get you is that you can field more men at once. But once war slows down to a grinding progress, the only thing that really matters is what fraction of your population you can sacrifice without breaking down.
Assuming your total pool is men aged 20-50, that might be around 30M for Russia and 8M for Ukraine; if every casualty costs you 2-3 (mainly attacker disadvantage, tracks with observed numbers) and you can use a lesser fraction because your civilians are less supportive/committed, then that numbers game is already kinda lost.
There is another aspect to this: As an attacker, it is important to make some kind of progress; throwing bodies at a static frontline for no gain except killing a lesser (!) fraction of defenders is really bad for morale.
Russia was able to "successfully" trade lives for territorial gains over the past years. But those trades are only becoming worse; the previous months saw extremely high losses and very little gains by comparison.
If things just continue and western support does not suddenly collapse, I hope/expect this war to end in some kind of negotiation within a year.
mcphage 44 minutes ago [-]
> As in, can they issue the decree?
I'm not the person you're replying to, but I'm assuming that the question isn't "can the issue the decree", but instead "can they actually bring a large number of new soldiers onto the battlefield?"
The Ukranian war is stuck in a slightly dystopian equilibrium because neither side can afford to gain WW2-scale air superiority, or even Iraq-war levels of air superiority. The increase in use of cruise missiles by Ukranians against strategic oil infrastructure may be the only way of changing that.
somenameforme 5 hours ago [-]
It's not about cost, but possibility. Iran is a relatively mid-tier power, and yet is still producing and flying drones/missiles in spite of the US blowing a huge chunk of our entire arsenal on it. The days of 'air superiority' in the classical sense, where you control the air domain and your opponent can do nothing about it, are simply over. And that means nearly all tactics that rely on air superiority are also obsolete.
The most likely scenario is what we're seeing in Ukraine. Wars turning into battles of attrition. Two sides face off and whoever runs out of soldiers (or another finite resource) first, ends up catastrophically collapsing at some point. There is a great thing about this. It means that the cost of war is going to skyrocket. No more flying over, dropping some bombs, and waving a victory flag. If you want to win, it's going to take a lot of suffering, and not just of the other side.
AnimalMuppet 5 hours ago [-]
The allies gained air superiority in World War II only after several years of battles of attrition. The US could, perhaps, do that in Iran as well... but the price would be high, higher than the administration is willing to pay.
horsawlarway 4 hours ago [-]
I'm not sure they can. At least not without doing what the above poster suggested and winning a war of resource attrition that prevents Iran from making/buying any more drones or missiles.
I feel like the problem is that there's nothing to "control" anymore. It used to be that getting a plane into the air required a large factory to produce it, training grounds to prepare people to fly it, and then a runway to actually launch it.
All of which were relatively vulnerable to disruption. You can bomb/shell any of those, and meaningfully disrupt the enemies capabilities to contest your air superiority.
Now a guy in the field can just throw a drone and it's up.
Worse, the drone itself is disposable and cheap, piloted by computer, and produced in mass quantities by 3rd parties who you can't meaningfully bomb/disrupt (at least not without starting another world war).
So what does "control" actually look like in that case?
Israel determined they would end the ability of Hamas to launch attacks from Gaza; they have done this by totally flattening the place, killing a huge number of civilians and displacing the rest.
Now, you may say that the idea of having a multiple-hundred-kilometer wide bombed out mass murder security zone between the West and Russia is an idea too terrible to contemplate, except .. that was the Russian objective in starting the war. To use Ukraine as an occupied dead zone.
Similarly, the US can't render Iran unable to stop attacking them without a ground invasion, which would have to proceed from Iraq (who would have to be coerced into permitting this!), in the manner of the Iran-Iraq war (~500k casualties). Sensible people understood this which is why the peace deal existed. Trump blowing that up has started a war which will continue with some level of intensity for years.
AnimalMuppet 40 minutes ago [-]
Look, I am very much not an apologist for Russia and their invasion of Ukraine, and their goal was definitely to use it as a buffer. But a dead zone? Didn't they want the industry? You don't get that if you kill everyone.
stackghost 3 hours ago [-]
The Allies didn’t have the technological means to gain air superiority over Europe until the latter half of the war. They had no aerial refuelling and no fighters with sufficient range to fly sorties from e.g. England.
Once long range escort fighters like the P-51 and high altitude Soviet fighters like the later Yakovlev/Lavochkin models came into the picture then they achieved superiority quite quickly.
wtch98 5 hours ago [-]
The Nazis failed to gain air superiority over the UK in 1940, it was close, but they still failed. The battle took three months.
One advantage the UK had was their pilots who were shot down would parachute out, jump on a train, and be back in the air a few hours later, where German pilots were captured.
tosapple 5 hours ago [-]
it's not a good thing, imagine an AI claiming (with drones and kin) an area where inputs like pure silicon or germanium are mined. mining operations run the risk of becoming carbon lifeform exclusion zones at some point as we them they occupy like termites the land.
edit, forgot to mention africa is frequently the victim of parasitism. i hope it doesn't end this way.
pmg101 6 hours ago [-]
For myself and other interested readers: what effects do you expect from such an increase in use of cruise missiles in shifting the equilibrium?
ceejayoz 6 hours ago [-]
Economic damage sufficient to put an end to the war?
simonh 2 hours ago [-]
That takes incredible amounts of economic damage. The Iranian and Ukrainian economies have both been poleaxed and they’re still in their respective fights. The North Korean economy is a sad joke, they’re in perpetual bouts of starvation, yet they still have nukes.
Economic harm can make beating a nation militarily possible, or less hard, but you still need to beat them militarily and if that means boots in the ground it’s never easy.
pjc50 1 hours ago [-]
Yes. It requires continuously destroying enough refinery capacity that petrol rationing isn't enough and the enemy military is constrained in their operations by lack of fuel, as ultimately happened to Japan and Germany. That is .. a lot of damage.
Vladimir Putin is 74 years old.
gadders 3 hours ago [-]
The trouble with damaging oil infrastructure is it harms your allies (via increased prices and decreased global supply) as much as your enemies.
The EU still buys oil and gas from Russia (albeit at reduced levels).
ceejayoz 3 hours ago [-]
That goes both ways; the EU's purchases of Russian oil/gas harm its allies.
spicyusername 6 hours ago [-]
Pretty horrific to consider
Jamesbeam 3 hours ago [-]
Ideally, not at all. But here we are.
One solution is to rotate all of the current political administration of a country to the frontline for the first three months of a war automatically.
If they are too old to fight, they can take care of the wounded at the frontline or do other services, like logistics and cooking, but their life must be at risk at all times, just like the ones of the men and women they usually send into war, without participating in the meatgrinder themselves.
Same goes for military leadership, it was dishonourable to stay back and command your troops for most of the time humans have fought wars.
The current way needs to end, as it’s setting the wrong kind of incentive for military leadership, the same way it does for the political leadership.
Since everyone can get elected, and being an elected representative does not require anyone to possess any special skills that no one else can provide, they can just be replaced with randomly drawn citizens during wartime.
Every three months you rotate, the people who survived the frontline will automatically take a seat in the parliament for the next cycle, as they have the most incentive to end the war quickly, and the personal experience of every woman and every man who gets sent to the frontline afterwards.
You need to give the politicians an incentive to choose peace over filling their pockets from a position of privilege. The only way to do that is have them experience war outside their patriot battery protected million dollar mansions and government buildings.
Eisenkot is a good example. I doubt under him the future IDF campaigns will be run like the ones Netanyahu did, because Netanyahu and his family and friends were well protected and only concerned with building Gaza into a riviera, while Eisenkot had to sacrifice his children to protect the country.
If it comes to actual combat between armies, the best strategy is to minimise civilian casualties and to create a scenario where you can operate freely against the enemy.
This might rub many people the wrong way, but how Israel fought the Gaza war was incredibly effective because they didn’t need to care for Israeli civilians in the combat zone. Every bomb they dropped was dropped on the enemy, seen from a military perspective.
If Ukraine had done evacuation orders at the start of the war and pushed for one big civilian evacuation while establishing defence positions, the war would be long over and Russia would have lost.
If everything that moves beyond the first line of contact is the enemy, you can just go all-in. And that is what is necessary to end a war quickly and with minimized civilian loss of life.
But we all know they would never pick that approach, because it’s easier to sacrifice other people than yourself in a time of war.
Generals like Eisenkot, as many flaws as the man might have, are a rare breed.
I could also name fifty marines who would jump on a grenade to protect you as a civilian immediately, but not a single US General.
Wars today are fought by fat and lazy people from offices for profit, and unless we demand more from our political and military leaders, your legs will get blown off by a drone long before any of theirs.
And the Putins and Trumps and even the Zelenskyys of this world are fine with that. But you shouldn’t.
Kuyawa 4 hours ago [-]
If I had nukes and you crossed over my border just once, I'd bomb your capital city into oblivion and get done with it
I believe they are just using this war as a test for new weapons, there is no other reason to keep this going on for so long. War in Iraq showed us that full air power is enough to topple any government in less than a week, and that was more than two decades ago. Russia has the military power to erase Ukraine and Europe from the map and they haven't done it, what's their long run strategy?
saagarjha 4 hours ago [-]
You mean threaten to do so. Launching nukes doesn’t really seem like it leads to positive outcomes, but having them might.
gherkinnn 3 hours ago [-]
> War in Iraq showed us that full air power is enough to topple any government in less than a week
Wrong. There hasn't been a single instance of strategic objectives being achieved by air power alone.
> Russia has the military power to erase Ukraine and Europe from the map
Do they? Almost half a million dead soldiers and they don't have much to show for it.
> What is their long run strategy
You make it sound as if there's a grand plan. The three-day special operation failed, Ukraine didn't buckle, and Russia continued to throw meat at the problem.
gadders 4 hours ago [-]
>>War in Iraq showed us that full air power is enough to topple any government in less than a week
I don't think the Iran conflict is showing that. I think you will always needs boots on the ground.
Someone 4 hours ago [-]
> War in Iraq showed us that full air power is enough to topple any government in less than a week.
> The first CIA team entered Iraq on 10 July 2002.
> At 5:34 am Baghdad time on 20 March 2003 (9:34 pm, 19 March EST) the surprise military invasion of Iraq began
> On 9 April, Baghdad fell, ending Saddam's 24‑year rule.
Even ignoring months of built-up, that’s over a week, and it involved an invasion by infantry.
slibhb 4 hours ago [-]
This is an insane comment on so many levels.
Using nuclear weapons would be against Russia's war aims (to control Ukraine, not destroy it). It would also unite the world behind Ukraine more than it already is, make it much more likely that NATO countries get involved, and risk a real nuclear war.
The idea that there's some conspiracy to prolong the war is bizarre. The truth is simple: Russia's military performed very poorly in the first part of the war, the Ukrainians performed better than expected, and now, due to drones, it's very hard for either side to make much progress.
Finally, the US invasion of Iraq is not remotely comparable to the situation in Ukraine for too many reasons to list. In fact, there's plenty of evidence that even a large, well-coordinated air campaign can't topple a determined regime.
stackghost 4 hours ago [-]
Russian combined-arms coordination was shockingly ineffective at the outset of the war.
The fact that the Ukrainian Air Force were still flying combat sorties more than a year later indicates that Russia doesn’t actually have as much conventional military power as previously thought.
9cb14c1ec0 4 hours ago [-]
This is more important that people realize. If the Russian airforce could freely fly over Ukraine, it would make Ukraine's logistics almost impossible and the war would end.
jghn 5 hours ago [-]
How should armies fight?
The leaders of both belligerents should be locked in a room and forced to settle things on their own.
lotsofpulp 4 hours ago [-]
What if there is only 1 belligerent?
walrus01 6 hours ago [-]
A fair bit of the modern era change (2022 and later) is: "Well, IEDs fly now..."
spwa4 6 hours ago [-]
Only if you have at least hundreds of millions to invest in it.
Of course, Iran does and keeps attacking everyone. If the news is right, they're trying lots of sabotage actions in Europe now. Will they move up to IEDs?
walrus01 5 hours ago [-]
I'm not sure what you mean by that, I was referring to the immediate eastern front Ukrainian situation of improvised munitions on things as small as quadcopters with 10" size propellers and cheap carbon fiber plate frames.
You don't need hundreds of millions or even dozens of millions or even 1 million to embark on a somewhat effective "strap explosives to a small FPV UAV" program.
spwa4 5 hours ago [-]
At distance, you need high tens low hundreds of drones to guarantee you'll get through. Also, to do real damage they do seem to need to be multiple tens of kilograms of weight.
So "strap a grenade to a DJI" is only ever going to work if you have someone launch it 100 meter from a target they can see, because you won't have reliable radio near the target with the normal equipment. And I wonder if there's really going to be that much of a difference between that and launching a grenade (you know, with those an military grenade launcher). I imagine that would be devastatingly effective against a target or a crowd if either you launch 10 grenades or it's not immediately clear it's a grenade to the target. Of course you could automate those too, but it'd be significantly more complex than a DJI FPV drone.
ceejayoz 5 hours ago [-]
> you won't have reliable radio near the target with the normal equipment
Fiber optic drones have been a thing for several years in the Ukraine conflict, and on-device visual guidance is starting to be a thing.
bluGill 4 hours ago [-]
There are downsides of fiber optic drones such that Ukraine prefers to use radio if they can get any through. Radio vs interference has been a constant battle in this war and depending on who has what you see different tactics in different parts of the battlefield and what you see changes
numpad0 4 hours ago [-]
Just wire a servo to the speaker of a cheap used phone, make a Jev-like model always running on it, name it "MechJev", and put it onto a SAM booster along an anti tank mine...
spwa4 4 hours ago [-]
anti tank mine is 20kg, that's not going to be any kind of standard drone ... and what do you mean a servo to the speaker?
BigTTYGothGF 5 hours ago [-]
> If the news is right
If the news is right, the Spaniards have sunk the USS Maine.
jareklupinski 7 hours ago [-]
in coliseums
jrm4 5 hours ago [-]
Nailed it.
War was already kind of stupid -- and with basically perfect information,today even more so.
Just do games.
t43562 5 hours ago [-]
The consequences of losing are what matter - it's why it would be foolish to accept the result of a game depending on who you are and who your opponent is.
jrm4 4 hours ago [-]
You're missing the point.
You don't do coliseums and sports to "decide a winner," that doesn't matter; that's what diplomacy is for.
War is not logical. War is a weird anomalous result of the fact that people, usually dudes, love complicated fighting, there's something about it in our nature.
t43562 4 hours ago [-]
FWIW I watch interviews where Russian citizens talk about how they expect Ukraine to reach a point where life is so bad that they decide they have to give up....and I think we in the West and the Ukranians are hoping the same about them.
There's no end to this because the Ukranians believe they know how bad it is to be subject to Russian mercy so they're not giving up and Russians are in the grip of the merciless system that the Ukranians don't want to join and they've found that it's difficult to oppose it and much easier to go along. It's all a situation controlled by one person whose vanity demands that millions are wounded and die. There's no negotiation - just the ultimate death of that person and the gamble about his replacement.
That's what Russians get for letting the apparatus of power capture them. It's what Ukranians get for being in the wrong place at the wrong time. The whole unsolvable problem is what we in Western Europe get for letting it gradually happen like we let so many bad things gradually happen until they're unsolvable messes.
We might draw some basic lessons e.g. to not allow "tall poppies" - nobody should be allowed power, via wealth or position, to capture the state. Excessive wealth can be excessively taxed until a balance point where we feel that a maximum power for some individual is not overly dangerous. The Roman Republic hit that problem, I think, just before it became an Empire and I certainly don't want to live though the modern versions of Nero, Caligula etc.
We also have to accept that it will be a few more centuries yet before we can relax on defence.
bluGill 4 hours ago [-]
War is just diplomacy by a different name. If you lose the battle of words you can always change the game by killing the people better at words than you. (this may or may not work).
War is perfectly logically in a lot of situations. Most of those haven't occurred int the last 100+ years - technology means we grow more than enough food for everybody.
There are a lot of unreasonable people out there and once one side decides war is correct the rest of us have no other logical choice but also go to war.
jareklupinski 4 hours ago [-]
that's fine, have it out in the arena
just keep it contained and away from kids
the article goes into "take the wars inside the cities" way too readily
rcxdude 2 hours ago [-]
Ok, someone has a war goal to kill you and everyone like you. You go to the arena and lose. Are you going to roll over and die? War happens when it is preferable to the alternative for both sides. You don't get to turn it into a game because it's what happens when all the games break down.
jareklupinski 2 hours ago [-]
> someone has a war goal to kill you and everyone like you. You go to the arena and lose. Are you going to roll over and die?
poland lost actual wars, wasn't on the map for some time, but it's there today
killing someone doesn't actually accomplish what you think it does
bluGill 2 hours ago [-]
Nobody is arguing that kill always accomplishes what you want (it sometimes does, don't cherry-pick examples to make a point that isn't justified)
We are arguing that large groups people who don't like their situation will often kill and there is nothing you can do about that except prepare for war.
jareklupinski 2 hours ago [-]
> large groups people who don't like their situation will often kill
thankfully there's more games than wars on right now
it's a long road to 0 :)
bluGill 4 hours ago [-]
That only works in books. The winners write the history. Anything you can do outside of the arena to cause you to win is going to be done, and if it works you rewrite the rules after the fact to make that form of cheating legal.
jareklupinski 2 hours ago [-]
> The winners write the history.
archaeology is a thing; otherwise we wouldve never known about Neanderthals
the future will be probably be less kind to mass murderers than peacemakers
rcxdude 2 hours ago [-]
War is perfectly logical. Almost everyone hates it, but it turns out there are some things that most people will hate more than war.
jareklupinski 4 hours ago [-]
> people, usually dudes, love complicated fighting
i still dont understand offsides rules
jrm4 4 hours ago [-]
AND THEY KEEP changing them.
It's funny, on one hand I was never a hardcore football fan, but I live in a college town and work at a big football school so I'm kind of default into it.
I really really love 17776 and the college football sequel on this.
If you don't know what I'm talking about I strongly recommend going in cold, spoiler free.
An important war that's not included in this article is America and Israel's genocide against Palestine. I think Armies should not commit genocide and war crimes. I apologize if I offended you with this comment.
eth0up 6 hours ago [-]
Against those who would abuse their power
jongjong 5 hours ago [-]
[flagged]
ozlikethewizard 5 hours ago [-]
I'm not sure if this is bait but in case it isn't. There is an obvious tangible difference between killing people and fighting to defend ones home and independence. Unfortunately, when fighting to defend oneself, one may have to consider the best way to do that. This isn't glorification, it's being practical, we'd all prefer peace but the Ukrainians aren't in that position.
If your nation only survives the winter because of a supply of grain and heating oil, then any threat that cuts off those supplies will kill you eventually. Often economic solutions suffice, but if you must protect yourself by kinetic means, then the battlefield is determined by the location (and supply lines) of the threat.
That is the problem with history. We can see what worked and didn't work. We can't nearly as easially know what is luck and what is good strategy/tactics. Many commenters talk about the current war as if everything changes, but it is never clear what is a major change and what is a blip that works now but soon be countered.
But it still doesn’t bother them too much. Consider that they haven’t even started a full mobilization yet. They just keep sending groups of soldiers who then get droned, send another and so on. Eventually a few get through, so it’s a slowly advancing front.
Can they? I'm inclined to see "we're not really trying yet" as cope, especially this far in.
> Eventually a few get through, so it’s a slowly advancing front.
This hasn't been the case in recent months, and 2026 saw a massive slowdown versus 2025. https://understandingwar.org/research/russia-ukraine/russian...
https://understandingwar.org/research/russia-ukraine/russian...
And their bet is very likely on the West surrendering soon enough due to its political instability, and stopping support to Ukraine. So speed, or even direction of front-line changes could be a secondary concern for them as long as this expectation is valid. They need just enough cannon fodder to prolong the war.
Things like "diesel deal", or pro-Russian statements of AfD, BSW and the likes certainly reinforce them in belief that it is valid. Also they probably pay, and influence (same way as USSR did) pundits, and politicians to make it happen. Taken as whole it looks like a strategy.
Something like 1 in 25 of Russian men have been killed or wounded in the war, in a country that was already aging and below replacement levels.
The diesel deal fell apart; the ships turned around. https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2026-11-10/ship-carr...
I don't deny Russia's trying to outlast Ukraine and the West, but I'm not sure broad mobilization is even possible.
As in, can they issue the decree? Absolutely. Would it lead to the regime toppling, possibly, as well. I am mainly going by the number of people they are sending in the meat grinder. They don't act like they are caring that much for them. It's a bit hard to fight with an enemy like that. But I think it's a bit hard to deny that they simply have more people to grind than Ukraine does. That's kind what Russians are hoping for, just grind down the Ukrainian manpower. The rest of the world is hoping for Putin to die and get a regime change, I think.
Russian population is not that much bigger (times 3-4 or so), and they can expect both higher losses (as attacker) and less willingness to sacrifice the same fraction of their population (because the war is existential for Ukraine but not for them).
So that approach might be doomed already; even if feasible numerically the margins should be pretty small.
It depends on absolute numbers too. If it's 1M vs 3M probably not a huge deal but we're talking 140M vs 40M, so that's 100M more. Obviously the majority won't be good for fighting. Going by the numbers they are willing throw into the grinder daily they don't act like a side that feels the constraints too badly, yet.
> because the war is existential for Ukraine but not for them
Agree, that's a good point. But it also matters how many men are left on the Ukraine's side who feel like they'd want to fight the existential battle. That's not resource that's infinite even if we assume the highest levels of patriotism and duty.
I am not sure how this conflict will end. It seems unlikely one side will be able just plow through and collapse the front enemy lines any time soon or ever. For Ukraine, at this point, they'd probably need some huge swarms of jam proof autonomous drones that can with a single operator cover 10s of sq kilometers.
Assuming your total pool is men aged 20-50, that might be around 30M for Russia and 8M for Ukraine; if every casualty costs you 2-3 (mainly attacker disadvantage, tracks with observed numbers) and you can use a lesser fraction because your civilians are less supportive/committed, then that numbers game is already kinda lost.
There is another aspect to this: As an attacker, it is important to make some kind of progress; throwing bodies at a static frontline for no gain except killing a lesser (!) fraction of defenders is really bad for morale.
Russia was able to "successfully" trade lives for territorial gains over the past years. But those trades are only becoming worse; the previous months saw extremely high losses and very little gains by comparison.
If things just continue and western support does not suddenly collapse, I hope/expect this war to end in some kind of negotiation within a year.
I'm not the person you're replying to, but I'm assuming that the question isn't "can the issue the decree", but instead "can they actually bring a large number of new soldiers onto the battlefield?"
The Ukranian war is stuck in a slightly dystopian equilibrium because neither side can afford to gain WW2-scale air superiority, or even Iraq-war levels of air superiority. The increase in use of cruise missiles by Ukranians against strategic oil infrastructure may be the only way of changing that.
The most likely scenario is what we're seeing in Ukraine. Wars turning into battles of attrition. Two sides face off and whoever runs out of soldiers (or another finite resource) first, ends up catastrophically collapsing at some point. There is a great thing about this. It means that the cost of war is going to skyrocket. No more flying over, dropping some bombs, and waving a victory flag. If you want to win, it's going to take a lot of suffering, and not just of the other side.
I feel like the problem is that there's nothing to "control" anymore. It used to be that getting a plane into the air required a large factory to produce it, training grounds to prepare people to fly it, and then a runway to actually launch it.
All of which were relatively vulnerable to disruption. You can bomb/shell any of those, and meaningfully disrupt the enemies capabilities to contest your air superiority.
Now a guy in the field can just throw a drone and it's up.
Worse, the drone itself is disposable and cheap, piloted by computer, and produced in mass quantities by 3rd parties who you can't meaningfully bomb/disrupt (at least not without starting another world war).
So what does "control" actually look like in that case?
Israel determined they would end the ability of Hamas to launch attacks from Gaza; they have done this by totally flattening the place, killing a huge number of civilians and displacing the rest.
Similarly, to end attacks from Lebanon, there is the "security zone": https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Israeli_occupation_of_Southern..., which comes with the ethnic cleansing of over a million people.
Now, you may say that the idea of having a multiple-hundred-kilometer wide bombed out mass murder security zone between the West and Russia is an idea too terrible to contemplate, except .. that was the Russian objective in starting the war. To use Ukraine as an occupied dead zone.
Similarly, the US can't render Iran unable to stop attacking them without a ground invasion, which would have to proceed from Iraq (who would have to be coerced into permitting this!), in the manner of the Iran-Iraq war (~500k casualties). Sensible people understood this which is why the peace deal existed. Trump blowing that up has started a war which will continue with some level of intensity for years.
Once long range escort fighters like the P-51 and high altitude Soviet fighters like the later Yakovlev/Lavochkin models came into the picture then they achieved superiority quite quickly.
One advantage the UK had was their pilots who were shot down would parachute out, jump on a train, and be back in the air a few hours later, where German pilots were captured.
edit, forgot to mention africa is frequently the victim of parasitism. i hope it doesn't end this way.
Economic harm can make beating a nation militarily possible, or less hard, but you still need to beat them militarily and if that means boots in the ground it’s never easy.
Vladimir Putin is 74 years old.
The EU still buys oil and gas from Russia (albeit at reduced levels).
One solution is to rotate all of the current political administration of a country to the frontline for the first three months of a war automatically.
If they are too old to fight, they can take care of the wounded at the frontline or do other services, like logistics and cooking, but their life must be at risk at all times, just like the ones of the men and women they usually send into war, without participating in the meatgrinder themselves.
Same goes for military leadership, it was dishonourable to stay back and command your troops for most of the time humans have fought wars.
The current way needs to end, as it’s setting the wrong kind of incentive for military leadership, the same way it does for the political leadership.
Since everyone can get elected, and being an elected representative does not require anyone to possess any special skills that no one else can provide, they can just be replaced with randomly drawn citizens during wartime.
Every three months you rotate, the people who survived the frontline will automatically take a seat in the parliament for the next cycle, as they have the most incentive to end the war quickly, and the personal experience of every woman and every man who gets sent to the frontline afterwards.
You need to give the politicians an incentive to choose peace over filling their pockets from a position of privilege. The only way to do that is have them experience war outside their patriot battery protected million dollar mansions and government buildings.
Eisenkot is a good example. I doubt under him the future IDF campaigns will be run like the ones Netanyahu did, because Netanyahu and his family and friends were well protected and only concerned with building Gaza into a riviera, while Eisenkot had to sacrifice his children to protect the country.
If it comes to actual combat between armies, the best strategy is to minimise civilian casualties and to create a scenario where you can operate freely against the enemy.
This might rub many people the wrong way, but how Israel fought the Gaza war was incredibly effective because they didn’t need to care for Israeli civilians in the combat zone. Every bomb they dropped was dropped on the enemy, seen from a military perspective.
If Ukraine had done evacuation orders at the start of the war and pushed for one big civilian evacuation while establishing defence positions, the war would be long over and Russia would have lost.
If everything that moves beyond the first line of contact is the enemy, you can just go all-in. And that is what is necessary to end a war quickly and with minimized civilian loss of life.
But we all know they would never pick that approach, because it’s easier to sacrifice other people than yourself in a time of war.
Generals like Eisenkot, as many flaws as the man might have, are a rare breed.
I could also name fifty marines who would jump on a grenade to protect you as a civilian immediately, but not a single US General.
Wars today are fought by fat and lazy people from offices for profit, and unless we demand more from our political and military leaders, your legs will get blown off by a drone long before any of theirs.
And the Putins and Trumps and even the Zelenskyys of this world are fine with that. But you shouldn’t.
I believe they are just using this war as a test for new weapons, there is no other reason to keep this going on for so long. War in Iraq showed us that full air power is enough to topple any government in less than a week, and that was more than two decades ago. Russia has the military power to erase Ukraine and Europe from the map and they haven't done it, what's their long run strategy?
Wrong. There hasn't been a single instance of strategic objectives being achieved by air power alone.
> Russia has the military power to erase Ukraine and Europe from the map
Do they? Almost half a million dead soldiers and they don't have much to show for it.
> What is their long run strategy
You make it sound as if there's a grand plan. The three-day special operation failed, Ukraine didn't buckle, and Russia continued to throw meat at the problem.
I don't think the Iran conflict is showing that. I think you will always needs boots on the ground.
Which war are you referring to? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Iraq_War:
> The first CIA team entered Iraq on 10 July 2002.
> At 5:34 am Baghdad time on 20 March 2003 (9:34 pm, 19 March EST) the surprise military invasion of Iraq began
> On 9 April, Baghdad fell, ending Saddam's 24‑year rule.
Even ignoring months of built-up, that’s over a week, and it involved an invasion by infantry.
Using nuclear weapons would be against Russia's war aims (to control Ukraine, not destroy it). It would also unite the world behind Ukraine more than it already is, make it much more likely that NATO countries get involved, and risk a real nuclear war.
The idea that there's some conspiracy to prolong the war is bizarre. The truth is simple: Russia's military performed very poorly in the first part of the war, the Ukrainians performed better than expected, and now, due to drones, it's very hard for either side to make much progress.
Finally, the US invasion of Iraq is not remotely comparable to the situation in Ukraine for too many reasons to list. In fact, there's plenty of evidence that even a large, well-coordinated air campaign can't topple a determined regime.
The fact that the Ukrainian Air Force were still flying combat sorties more than a year later indicates that Russia doesn’t actually have as much conventional military power as previously thought.
The leaders of both belligerents should be locked in a room and forced to settle things on their own.
Of course, Iran does and keeps attacking everyone. If the news is right, they're trying lots of sabotage actions in Europe now. Will they move up to IEDs?
You don't need hundreds of millions or even dozens of millions or even 1 million to embark on a somewhat effective "strap explosives to a small FPV UAV" program.
So "strap a grenade to a DJI" is only ever going to work if you have someone launch it 100 meter from a target they can see, because you won't have reliable radio near the target with the normal equipment. And I wonder if there's really going to be that much of a difference between that and launching a grenade (you know, with those an military grenade launcher). I imagine that would be devastatingly effective against a target or a crowd if either you launch 10 grenades or it's not immediately clear it's a grenade to the target. Of course you could automate those too, but it'd be significantly more complex than a DJI FPV drone.
Fiber optic drones have been a thing for several years in the Ukraine conflict, and on-device visual guidance is starting to be a thing.
If the news is right, the Spaniards have sunk the USS Maine.
War was already kind of stupid -- and with basically perfect information,today even more so.
Just do games.
You don't do coliseums and sports to "decide a winner," that doesn't matter; that's what diplomacy is for.
War is not logical. War is a weird anomalous result of the fact that people, usually dudes, love complicated fighting, there's something about it in our nature.
There's no end to this because the Ukranians believe they know how bad it is to be subject to Russian mercy so they're not giving up and Russians are in the grip of the merciless system that the Ukranians don't want to join and they've found that it's difficult to oppose it and much easier to go along. It's all a situation controlled by one person whose vanity demands that millions are wounded and die. There's no negotiation - just the ultimate death of that person and the gamble about his replacement.
That's what Russians get for letting the apparatus of power capture them. It's what Ukranians get for being in the wrong place at the wrong time. The whole unsolvable problem is what we in Western Europe get for letting it gradually happen like we let so many bad things gradually happen until they're unsolvable messes.
We might draw some basic lessons e.g. to not allow "tall poppies" - nobody should be allowed power, via wealth or position, to capture the state. Excessive wealth can be excessively taxed until a balance point where we feel that a maximum power for some individual is not overly dangerous. The Roman Republic hit that problem, I think, just before it became an Empire and I certainly don't want to live though the modern versions of Nero, Caligula etc.
We also have to accept that it will be a few more centuries yet before we can relax on defence.
War is perfectly logically in a lot of situations. Most of those haven't occurred int the last 100+ years - technology means we grow more than enough food for everybody.
There are a lot of unreasonable people out there and once one side decides war is correct the rest of us have no other logical choice but also go to war.
just keep it contained and away from kids
the article goes into "take the wars inside the cities" way too readily
poland lost actual wars, wasn't on the map for some time, but it's there today
killing someone doesn't actually accomplish what you think it does
We are arguing that large groups people who don't like their situation will often kill and there is nothing you can do about that except prepare for war.
thankfully there's more games than wars on right now
it's a long road to 0 :)
archaeology is a thing; otherwise we wouldve never known about Neanderthals
the future will be probably be less kind to mass murderers than peacemakers
i still dont understand offsides rules
It's funny, on one hand I was never a hardcore football fan, but I live in a college town and work at a big football school so I'm kind of default into it.
I really really love 17776 and the college football sequel on this.
If you don't know what I'm talking about I strongly recommend going in cold, spoiler free.
https://www.sbnation.com/a/17776-football